From Detroit to San Jose, Calif., cities around the country have created violence prevention task forces that engage the voices and experiences of people on the streets — especially young people and ex-offenders. Wednesday’s release of a survey of 400 local at-risk youths by CeasefirePA, the Black Political Empowerment Project and the Greater Pittsburgh Coalition Against Violence should inspire such a model here.
Over the last seven months, the Post-Gazette has called for giving Pittsburgh’s young people and ex-offenders a voice in the debate on violence. We remain convinced it is the only promising way forward.
Survey results drawn from local young people are sobering but hardly surprising, reflecting the experiences of youth in most urban areas. Of the 400 at-risk young people who responded, almost half had personally witnessed an act of gun violence, and 10% had witnessed four or more gun assaults. Only about 60% feel consistently safe or somewhat safe in their classrooms and neighborhoods; more than 80% feel little or nothing is being done to address the problem of violence.
And a heartbreaking 57% had lost a member of their own families to guns.
The survey also should have asked if the respondents had parents or family members who had been incarcerated. Statistically, a child with an incarcerated parent is seven times more likely to go to prison than other children.
Behind these numbers are human beings who live daily under the shadow of fear and dread, whose lives are punctuated by moments of terror and trauma. This way of living warps the minds and hearts of everyone in a community, but especially impressionable young people, whose hopes and dreams are constrained by the constant threat of violence. It becomes impossible to imagine anything better, and the cycle of trauma continues.
Read More
The only way to break it is to listen to those who are in it. Radical change cannot be effectively imposed from the outside; it must begin on the inside. The means bringing young people on the inside to the table, along with ex-offenders who want to help heal a community they once harmed.
Mayor Ed Gainey has proposed ambitious anti-violence initiatives, but his plans are still light on details and reflect a top-down approach that will be less effective without input from people who have lived in the shadow of gun violence.
One key component can be executed quickly: Create a task force of young people, similar to the youth who took part in the survey, to advise the city’s elected and non-elected leaders, as the debate on gun violence moves forward. Such a group also would give young people opportunities for leadership and a real stake in their community.
Mr. Gainey understands the importance of first-hand experience. He walked the streets of the South Side on a rowdy weekend night to learn how to respond to the problems there. And he still lives in Lincoln-Lemington, within walking distance of some of the neighborhoods most affected by gun violence.
The mayor’s commitment to reducing violence in his community, and for providing a more hopeful future for its young people, cannot be questioned. But he must avoid the trap of simply asking the usual suspects for answers. He needs to get people who have lived in the shadow of violence directly involved.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.