On a recent episode of the podcast The Rest is History, top British historian Dominic Sandbrook asked about the U.S. Civil War: “Why didn’t the Northerners just let the South go?”
It’s a question, he conceded, that might sound strange to American ears. We’re used to the thinking of the idea of the Union as inviolable. But now, with America more starkly divided than at any time since the mid-nineteenth century, it’s a question worth pondering.
Northerners, said Mr. Sandbrook, “might well say, ‘Listen, we’re a lot better off without those clowns. They’re bad people . . . they’re backward.’” Why, the historian wondered, were Northerners prepared to lose 300,000 people to force Southerners back into the Union?
Adam Smith, an Oxford scholar of American history, offered an answer that might seem quaint today: Nineteenth-century Americans believed that, if the experiment in democracy and constitutional government failed, “the light of freedom would dim around the world.” Back then, people genuinely believed America was, in the words of Abraham Lincoln, “the last best hope of earth.” No cost was too great to keep that hope alive.
Fast forward more than 150 years, and the sense is growing every day that there are millions of “bad” and “backward” people whom the country would be better off without. Indeed, if some states were to announce tomorrow that they were leaving to form a new country, would the rest of the nation attempt to preserve the union at all costs? Or would it bid the clowns adieu and carry on?
What gave our forebears the strength to preserve the Union was a deep-seated sense that America had a purpose beyond itself — a moral and even spiritual destiny for the good of humanity. And in order to fulfill that purpose, the country had to constantly purify itself of injustice.
For its own sake and for the sake of the world, America needs to rediscover that sense of shared mission today.
In the complacency of the post-World War II and post-Cold War era, everyday Americans — and especially their leaders — have forgotten that keeping a country together is hard work. It requires wisdom and courage and other virtues — generosity and prudence and humility — to be modeled by leaders and practiced by the people. It requires holding strong principles, but also understanding and respecting others’ principles. It requires the ability to see and to seek common goods that are more important than one’s own.
When these moral muscles atrophy, it weakens the bonds that hold the country together. And it weakens America’s example of liberty and justice for all, flawed as it may be, to a world that still needs it.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.