Public figures have trivialized the Holocaust for decades as a stand-in for things they don't like. A new immigration policy? It's concentration camps all over again! Government-mandated COVID-19 safety policies and vaccine mandates? Nazism! A riot and assault on the U.S. Capitol? Straight from the Nazi playbook! (Actually, given that some rioters were dressed in Nazi regalia, that's a more reasonable comparison.)
Both sides of the political aisle do this. The Holocaust should not be reduced to a rhetorical weapon. That minimizes the actual horror of the Holocaust, which was the state-sponsored extermination of 6 million Jews. Using it to punch up an argument not only trivializes the event itself, but it helps erase our corporate memory of the event and people lost — and its continued effects on Jewish Americans. It obscures what we should learn from it.
The best way to combat such trivialization is through education. Teachers and parents are the country's first line of defense against a human tendency to forget such horrors.
One local teacher deserves special praise. Bravo to Dan Shaner, recently named Pittsburgh's 2021-22 Holocaust Educator of the Year, an award given by the Holocaust Center of Pittsburgh. The Baldwin resident and Baldwin-Whitehall School District teacher took it upon himself to educate himself and others on a subject that, studies show, fewer and fewer students are learning about with any depth and accuracy.
Mr. Shaner’s lessons take a broad and interdisciplinary approach to Holocaust education. He places the the genocide in the context of millennia of human history and hate, and he teaches excerpts of Holocaust literature from “The Diary of Anne Frank” to the psychologist Viktor Frankl’s “Man’s Search for Meaning.”
In 2018, a survey by the Conference on Jewish Material Claims Against Germany noted that 41% of Americans were unable to identify Auschwitz as a concentration camp. Nearly one-third of Americans grossly underestimated the number of Jews killed in the Holocaust.
“Hatred, no matter what form it takes, can have devastating results not just on victims but on the world around us,” Mr. Shaner told the Post-Gazette’s Joshua Axelrod. “It’s not so much that we’re doomed to repeat our history because it gets uglier every time. We need to know early enough that we must stand up.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.