African Americans make up nearly three quarters of the players in the National Football League. Since 1946, when Black players were formally allowed to participate in the national sport, they’ve excelled at every position, including quarterback, a role reserved for white athletes until the 1980s.
Despite the strides across the color line on the field, front offices have continued to resist change. The introduction of the Rooney Rule in the early 2000s required owners to at least interview Black coaching and management prospects for job openings. Still, the head coaches and offensive and defensive coordinators of the 32 franchise teams remain overwhelmingly white.
There are now six Black NFL head coaches, counting Todd Bowles, who was elevated this week to head coach of the Tampa Bay Buccaneers when Bruce Arians retired. Mike Tomlin of the Pittsburgh Steelers is one of them.
The Rooney Rule did not result in a flowering of opportunity for non-white head coaches and offensive and defensive coordinators, despite the mandate that two minorities or a woman be interviewed for every open slot.
When the NFL announced last week that it had enacted diversity measures to ensure that each team would have to hire at least one assistant coach on its offensive staff who was a minority, Mr. Tomlin reacted with skepticism that it would increase the pool of minority candidates for the top jobs. He has yet to see any enthusiasm for genuine change or a wholehearted embrace of the initiatives already on the books.
“I’m more a show-me guy as opposed to a guy that sits around and talks about things,” Coach Tomlin said speaking at the NFL’s annual meeting. He’s right to be cynical given the NFL’s abysmal record on diversity among its senior football operations.
Former Miami Dolphins head coach Brian Flores was fired after three seasons despite a winning record. In a lawsuit he filed against the NFL and three of its teams, Mr. Flores, who is now the senior defensive assistant/linebackers coach of the Steelers, alleged that his interviews for head coaching positions with the Giants and Broncos were shams meant to follow the letter of the Rooney Rule, but not its spirit. That suit will proceed despite his employment with Pittsburgh.
Todd Bowles, who is Black, was given the top job in Tampa Bay, though no other candidates were considered because his predecessor retired after March 1, when franchises lock their talent into exclusive contracts to prevent them from talking to other teams. This is a big loophole in the Rooney Rule that has to be addressed because it makes most of the talent pool unavailable.
That’s why Mr. Tomlin has identified “hiring itself” as the biggest impediment to the goal of racially inclusive team leadership in the NFL. “I think that we’ve pecked around the entire discussion and subject and we’ve done a lot of beneficial things, but we’ve got to land the plane,” he said. “We’ve got to hire capable candidates.”
Well said, Coach.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.