Nearly three and a half years have passed since the horrific mass murder of 11 worshippers at the Tree of Life synagogue. Now that a federal judge has denied a motion by the defense for a change of venue, the community is itching for the wheels of justice to proceed.
The Sixth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution also guarantees defendants “the right to a speedy and public trial, by an impartial jury.” These rights protect the accused, who are entitled to a presumption of innocence, and the victims and the community, who suffer the pain of prolonged litigation.
To be sure, justice can take time, especially with the most serious crimes. And the case of the United States v. Robert Bowers of Baldwin is among the most grave in U.S. history. Some delays have been unavoidable, such as the retirement of U.S. Judge Donetta Ambrose, who presided over the case since Bowers’ arraignment in early 2019. Others may be the deliberate tactics of an experienced defense team led by attorney Judy Clarke.
But the chief impediment to a speedy resolution of this case is the U.S. Justice Department’s demand that it be tried under the death penalty. In the interest of timely justice, it should drop its call for death, as some leaders of the Jewish congregations attacked on Oct. 27, 2018, have asked from the beginning.
Death penalty trials demand more expert witnesses, investigations and evaluations. They contain automatic rights to appeal. Jury selection is more complex.
Even if a death penalty conviction survived the inevitable appeals — and the current moratorium on federal executions — protracted post-conviction challenges would likely delay an execution for nearly 20 years, keeping the psychic wounds of this tragedy open and festering.
There are, in general, good reasons for the myriad of costly and lengthy legal procedures meant to protect the accused and avoid mistakes that the death penalty makes irreversible. Since the United States resumed executions in the 1970s, more than 180 death-row prisoners have been exonerated because of wrongful convictions, the Death Penalty Information Center reports. Without those protections, innocent people die.
Small wonder seven states have abolished the death penalty since 2009. Pennsylvania has a death-penalty statute, but Gov. Tom Wolf imposed a moratorium on executions in 2015.
Even setting aside the compelling moral issues of capital punishment, Pennsylvania is a case study in its practical problems. Since 1976, more than 400 Pennsylvania prisoners were sentenced to death. Securing those convictions and defending them against post-conviction appeals — which dragged on for years, even decades — cost the state roughly $1 billion. Yet most of those convictions were ultimately overturned and re-sentenced to mandatory life. Another 10 death row prisoners were exonerated. Only three were executed.
In the case of the United States v. Robert Bowers, the government owes the families of victims, and the people of Pittsburgh, the timely salve of justice — not a futile cry for vengeance. It should drop the death penalty and set the course for a speedy trial and imminent resolution.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.