Much-acclaimed graphic novels, some that have been around for decades, are having a moment right now. Unfortunately, it isn’t a good one.

In January, Art Spiegelman’s “Maus: A Survivor’s Tale: My Father Bleeds History,” a Pulitzer Prize-winning graphic novel about the Holocaust that has been used by educators since the early 1990s, was removed from the 8th-grade curriculum of a Tennessee school district because of the presence of an obscene word and a nude concentration camp victim.

Closer to home, another acclaimed graphic novel incurred the wrath of a few parents days before it was scheduled to be taught in a ninth grade honors English class at Franklin Regional Senior High School.

“Persepolis: The Story of a Childhood” by Marjane Satrapi has been a critical and commercial favorite of young people and critics since 2004. It is the story of a young girl coming of age during the Iranian Revolution and the horrendous Iran-Iraq war that threw her country into chaos.

Advertise with us

Ms. Satrapi’s book, a perennial bestseller for nearly 20 years, especially with young girls and women, had already been approved for use by the curriculum committee at Franklin Regional a year ago. At the 11th hour, a few parents have come forward to object to it, causing the curriculum committee to put “Persepolis” on pause.

On Wednesday, Franklin Regional School Board members, parents, teachers and the curriculum committee met to discuss the decision to pause the book.

It was a respectful airing of opinions about the value of teaching students in a 9th grade honors class about young people in circumstances and cultures far removed from their own. The parents of students who want their children to wrestle with new ideas made a good case for trusting teachers to do their jobs without having to fear a few parents wielding a veto.

Those who objected to “Persepolis” cited profanity, violence and “liberal ideology” as reasons not to reinstate the book. It is not a persuasive argument, especially when their children are permitted to opt out and study another book.

After all sides had been heard, the curriculum committee did not lift the pause. Instead, it will meet and send a formal recommendation to the school board about teaching “Persepolis” to 9th grade students.

Advertise with us

It is not a foregone conclusion that the curriculum committee will recommend canceling the book now that the voices of parents who want students to benefit from exposure to new ideas and challenging books are on the record, too. The committee should follow its conscience and commonsense to reinstate the book.

There’s a reason “Persepolis” has been popular with young people for nearly a generation. They can relate to the 14-year-old lead character’s struggle for identity in a world where authorities insist on doing their thinking for them. Perhaps this is the real reason that a few parents want to silence yet another great book.