It didn’t take long for Pittsburghers to jump on the electric scooter trend. The rules of the road are having to play catch-up.
The city launched a two-year pilot program on July 9 in partnership with electric scooter operator Spin. Since then, customers have taken between 1,500 and 4,300 rides per day on the 900 e-scooters available. Riders use smartphones to download an app to use the scooters. They must put at least $10 in their Spin accounts before riding, and they’re charged $1 per ride plus 39 cents per minute. Spin says it provides discounts to individuals with lower incomes.
Complaints piled up fast. So did scooters — on sidewalks, in parking lots, at intersections and on lawns. And the city received calls about riders’ behavior, too. Two people even were recorded riding their scooters through the Liberty Tunnel.
Spin says it takes safety and responsibility seriously and that it warns, then fines and eventually suspends accounts for users who do not. The company goes through the city each night to collect wayward scooters, sets their maximum speed at 15 mph and equips them with shutoffs if a rider goes on a road where it shouldn’t.
Clearly, the system is not fail-safe.
Pittsburgh City Council is set to consider on Wednesday a measure proposed by Mayor Bill Peduto to mirror both Spin’s policies and provisions of the state’s vehicle code that were enacted in June. Council’s bill would mandate that drivers be at least 18, go no faster than 15 mph, and only use bike lanes and roads with speed limits of 25 mph or less. Sidewalks are off-limits, and parking is limited to legal parking spaces, designated corrals and public bike racks.
The pros and cons being witnessed in Pittsburgh follow a pattern that’s been repeated in other cities. They can be a good alternative for able-bodied individuals taking short trips. Surveys in Minneapolis, Chicago, San Francisco and Arlington, Va., all show scooter trips typically replaced the use of personal cars and ride-hailing services. And a report by the National Association of City Transportation Officials said so-called “micromobility options” can cut down on congestion and pollution.
Other cities have had to adapt as scooter use increases. Some have limited the number of companies permitted to offer scooters, which makes it easier to monitor compliance. In Pittsburgh, Spin is the only provider, and the lesson could be to keep it that way.
It’s also important to remember that e-scooters should not be considered a replacement for ample affordable public transportation. The cost per mile on scooters can be far higher than buses and T service. They’re not an option for youngsters, impaired individuals or the elderly. And forget about using them in inclement weather.
While council considers how to deal with scooters, it might consider going further than the current measure, such as requiring riders to be licensed drivers and mandating helmets and reflective clothing.
Unfortunately, common sense cannot be legislated. We’re talking to you, tunnel riders.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.