Like a digital Library of Alexandria, the Internet Archive is among the most altruistic and noble projects of the last 30 years. With a mission to provide “universal access to all knowledge,” the San Francisco-based organization has worked ceaselessly to digitize all manner of books, images, recordings, videos, games, websites and more.

But, in recent months, the Internet Archive has become the target of political pressure from those unable or unwilling to see its value.

The first conflict resulted from the Internet Archive’s decision in March to launch a National Emergency Library program that would allow people free access to more than 1.4 million books while classrooms and libraries were shuttered by the COVID-19 pandemic. That program, originally meant to run through the end of June, was ended June 1 after the Internet Archive was hit with a lawsuit by major publishing houses and public criticism from Sen. Thom Tillis, R-N.C.

Mr. Tillis has now set his sights on the Archive’s Great 78 Program, a community initiative geared toward the preservation, research and discovery of 78 rpm records. More than 3 million of these records, made of fragile shellac, were produced between 1898 and 1950, and the Archive wants to catalog and digitize them all.

Advertise with us

The project recently received a major boost when the Archive purchased more than 500,000 records from Bop Street Records, one of Seattle’s oldest record stores, which was forced to close because of the pandemic. Mr. Tillis believes that the Internet Archive will use this acquisition to violate copyright law.

“It is clear that these sound recordings were very recently for sale in a commercial record shop and likely contain many sound recordings that retain significant commercial value,” Mr. Tillis wrote in a letter to Brewster Kahle, the founder of the Internet Archive. “This raises serious alarms about copyright infringement.”

Mr. Tillis specifically cited the Orrin G. Hatch-Bob Goodlatte Music Modernization Act, which was passed in 2018 in an effort to modernize copyright law to deal with the embrace of digital streaming and downloading.

But the MMA allows for noncommercial “use” of recordings made prior to 1972. This exemption was created for exactly the sort of archival efforts that the Internet Archive is undertaking.

It is clear that the Internet Archive, prioritizing free access to information over profits, has run afoul of powerful interests in the media landscape. But its efforts are noble, its intentions are sound and it is unclear that the Archive even violated copyright protections, a convoluted and archaic subset of American law.

Mr. Tillis should focus his efforts on more nefarious forms of intellectual property theft, or work to more adequately clarify and modernize copyright law in the U.S. The Internet Archive, meanwhile, should continue its important work of making knowledge and historic culture available to as many people as possible.