If the stakes weren’t so high, it could be entertaining to watch the thrust and parry of the region’s two health care giants as they approach a pair of looming deadlines: their official divorce in the summer and the end of the annual Medicare open enrollment period this month.

Medicare subscribers have until Dec. 7 to pick their insurance provider for the coming year. As is to be expected, they’re being deluged with promotional materials and statements.

As the pages of the calendar turn, one of the biggest events in the history of health care in Western Pennsylvania approaches. After June 30, cross-network access between Highmark and UPMC will end, bringing to a final close consent decrees that allowed customers of one plan to use the other under given sets of circumstances. No more. The divorce will be final.

In the optimum environment, health insurance choices and decisions can be difficult waters to navigate for many Medicare-eligible consumers. But those waters are being churned further by information campaigns that are, at best, confusing and possibly misleading, to the extent that one wonders whether it is an intentional and unscrupulous tactic to sign up customers who don’t really understand exactly what they’re signing up for.

Advertise with us

Local insurance brokerage firms are reporting complaints from hundreds of clients and words like “ugly” have been used to describe the situation.

The situation is this: When consent decrees signed by Highmark and UPMC expire, Highmark’s Medicare members will lose in-network access to UPMC hospitals throughout the region. Most UPMC physicians also will be considered out-of-network for Highmark members.

To cushion the blow, Highmark introduced certain plans for 2019 with enhanced out-of-network benefits; there’s a small-print caveat that a member’s cost “may be greater than at the in-network level.” UPMC countered Highmark’s offer with a new rule that would require Highmark subscribers to pay upfront for the out-of-network UPMC services. That’s where it stands.

Some divorces become so bitter that the children are totally forgotten. The Pennsylvania Insurance Department and the state attorney general’s office need to keep watch over this separation. The combatants cannot police themselves and long ago, in the war to destroy each other, lost sight of the sick people who need them.