On Friday, Republican Jim Christiana closed his Harrisburg office, departing after five terms as state representative for the 15th District in Beaver County and an unsuccessful U.S. Senate bid last spring.

On Tuesday, the longtime critic of the looming Highmark-UPMC split opened fire on his legislative colleagues for not doing more to prevent, or now end, the ongoing health care war that may force consumers to choose between their long-term physician and their long-held insurance plan.

“Harrisburg doesn’t have the guts to stand up to them,” he told a roomful of executives at the Pittsburgh Business Group on Health’s annual community forum at the Pittsburgh Marriott City Center.

The reason legislators haven’t acted, he said, is self-preservation, which would argue against taking on the state’s largest non-governmental employer in Pittsburgh-based UPMC. Instead, it was left to members of then-Gov. Tom Corbett’s Cabinet to get UPMC and Highmark to agree on matching five-year consent decrees in 2014, giving the market and individuals time to make the transition. Those agreements are due to expire June 30.

Advertise with us

“My colleagues would love nothing more than to just hope and pray that these companies would come to an agreement,” Mr. Christiana said. “The problem is, it’s not going to happen.”

Instead, he sees Pennsylvania becoming a health care “oligopoly” where UPMC, Highmark, Geisinger, and perhaps one or two others in the Philadelphia area control the statewide market, threatening community hospitals and even smaller health systems such as Heritage Valley in his home district.

Mr. Christiana’s comments no doubt caught the ear of the day’s two other speakers from Pennsylvania Attorney General Josh Shapiro’s office: Executive Deputy Attorney General Jim Donahue and Chief Deputy Attorney General Tracy Wertz.

During their discussion at the forum, the two attorneys said their office will be proposing rule-making next month “to give us more tools” to fight unfair competition in the state. They declined to connect that effort to the scheduled UPMC-Highmark dissolution next summer, but Mr. Shapiro has made no secret that he’s troubled by the impact that split will have on consumers.

Mr. Christiana, for one, is convinced that Harrisburg should intervene — either with regulation or legislation. He thinks recent expansion by UPMC and Highmark eastward, through acquisitions and partnerships, may prompt legislators to act “because it’s no longer a Western Pennsylvania issue.”

Advertise with us

But he’s not waiting for that to happen, launching a public policy and communications business to take the issue on.

“I’ve known for a while that the traditional political establishment and the traditional lobbying community have been unable to deliver the change that the area needs,” Mr. Christiana said.

Among his suggestions: Have health care providers accept any willing insurer; make physician “non-compete” clauses unenforceable so patients can keep their doctors; and require hospitals to post online their costs for procedures and tests.

While campaigning statewide for the U.S. Senate, Mr. Christiana, 35, said he “realized that there are a lot of people, a lot of organizations that can effect change in our political process.”

He also believes his new firm, still getting its footing, puts him in a better position to marshal those forces.

Advertise with us

“A legislator has to be respectful of district lines, respectful of county lines, respectful of the seniority system within the chamber. On the outside, that evaporates overnight,” he said.

Steve Twedt: stwedt@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1963.