Their job is to protect and serve, not stonewall. So it is disconcerting that three Pittsburgh police officers have refused to testify before the Citizen Police Review Board, which is investigating why a suicidal woman was taken to the Allegheny County Jail instead of to mental health treatment in March 2015.
Rayden Sorock of Lawrenceville called 911 to report that the woman, who had a history of mental health issues, was threatening to harm herself with a scalpel. Mr. Sorock said Officer Matthew Gardner, one of the three officers who responded to the call, told him the woman would be taken for psychiatric help. Instead, she ended up at the Allegheny County Jail, charged with threatening the officers.
Rightly upset with that outcome, Mr. Sorock filed a complaint with the CPRB. To find out what happened, the CPRB subpoenaed Officer Gardner and the two other officers, Nicholas Papa and Christopher Rosato, involved in the call. The CPRB identified Officer Gardner as the subject of the complaint and the other two as witnesses.
Officer Gardner did not show up at the CPRB’s Jan. 26 hearing, while Officers Papa and Rosato appeared but declined to testify. Citing a provision in its contract, the police union claims the officers have no obligation to answer the CPRB’s questions. However, the CPRB is going to court May 15 to try to force the their testimony, claiming previous rulings require the officers’ cooperation.
This is one of two cases in which officers now are refusing to face the CPRB’s questions. Elizabeth Pittinger, CPRB executive director, said the second case involves a complaint about police making an inaccurate report about a traffic accident.
It is disheartening that police officers, who rely on the public’s cooperation to solve crimes, would shirk an opportunity to help another investigative agency resolve a complaint. As witnesses, Officers Papa and Rosato should have no qualms about testifying.
As the subject of the complaint, Officer Gardner’s reluctance is more understandable. But this is no excuse for his failing to appear at the hearing. If questioned, he would have had a right to avoid self-incrimination.
The officers’ handling of the call bears scrutiny. Officer Gardner had special training for responding to calls involving mental illness; he should have known that treatment, not jail, is the preferred course of action in these cases. The officers’ refusal to cooperate undercuts Mayor Bill Peduto’s efforts to improve police-community relations, including the recent launch of a pilot program dedicating a beat officer to each of 18 communities.
City officials last week refused to immediately give the Post-Gazette copies of police bureau policies that could have shed more light on how officers should have handled the call. The law department wants to review police policies before releasing them to make sure strategies and tactics aren’t publicized. But the bureau already should have a publicly available version of its policy manual. It’s ridiculous to have to have to wait for something as simple as a policy statement.
Officer Robert Swartzwelder, the police union president, noted that allegations of police conduct also are reviewed by the city Office of Municipal Investigations and the police bureau’s Office of Professional Standards. That, he said, means people unhappy with the police can “shop and get the result that they’re seeking.”
Not really. The CPRB, nearly 20 years old, is an independent agency established to investigate police misconduct. It does not have the authority to discipline officers, only make recommendations regarding personnel and policy. It serves a critical role — one that may be more respected if the CPRB gets a new order next month enforcing its subpoenas.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.