Eight days after an Allegheny County judge ordered three Pittsburgh police officers to testify before the Citizen Police Review Board, the board filed a second petition asking a judge to give the same order to another officer in an unrelated case.

The new petition, filed in the civil division of Allegheny County Common Pleas Court on Wednesday, asks a judge to force Officer Joseph Lippert to honor a subpoena that the CPRB issued as part of an investigation into his alleged misconduct during a 2015 traffic stop.

Officer Lippert refused to testify before the board when he was subpoenaed to a March public hearing. Such hearings are set so that members of the Citizen Police Review Board can gather facts about alleged misconduct.

Officer Lippert is accused of bungling the investigation into a traffic crash on Aug. 3, 2015, by failing to record witness information, incorrectly reporting the crash as a rear-end collision, putting the wrong time and date on a report about the crash and incorrectly assigning blame for the crash to a taxi driver.

Advertise with us

Officer Lippert is the fourth officer since November 2016 to refuse to testify before the board, executive director Elizabeth Pittinger said. Prior to November, officers routinely complied with the board’s subpoenas, she said.

But the requirement has been tested in court before — most recently this year, when three officers refused to testify about the arrest of a suicidal woman in 2015. In a May 23 ruling in that case, Judge John McVay Jr. ordered those three officers to comply with the CPRB’s subpoenas and testify.

Fraternal Order of Police Lodge 1 attorney Chris Cimballa said the union is still considering whether to appeal that decision, but said that it will fight the petition seeking to force Officer Lippert to testify.

“We’re disappointed in Judge McVay’s decision in the earlier case,” he said. “And we feel strongly in our position then as we do today.”

Officer Bob Swartzwelder, FOP president, said he expects the union to use the same arguments in Officer Lippert’s case that were used for the three officers before him.

Advertise with us

“We’ll await the opinion of this judge and then we’ll make an assessment of where we stand,” he said.

Ms. Pittinger said the courts have consistently sided with the CPRB on this issue, and said last week’s order reinforces that long-standing position.

“I don’t know why [the union] would expect a different outcome,” she said.

Shelly Bradbury: 412-263-1999, sbradbury@post-gazette.com or follow on Twitter @ShellyBradbury.