With inmate deaths and problems with the delivery of health care services at the Allegheny County Jail in recent years, members of the Jail Oversight Board should take their role seriously. That means doing more than attending board meetings, reviewing administrators’ reports and asking the occasional softball question. That means visiting the jail to assess operations firsthand and questioning employees, vendors and inmates about conditions there.
The board is divided over the active approach taken by board members Terri Klein, a former county councilwoman, and county Controller Chelsa Wagner, who have visited the jail unannounced and complained about care and other issues. In December, they raised questions about the number of pregnant women at the jail and recommended greater use of alternative placements for these inmates. More recently, they’ve sought details into a lockdown at the jail last month. That line of questioning prompted the board president, Common Pleas Judge David Cashman, to say the board’s role is to provide oversight, not management.
The distinction is valid, but Ms. Klein and Ms. Wagner have not come even close to crossing the line. Board members have a difficult job in keeping abreast of what happens in a taxpayer-financed facility cut off from public view. Making visits to the jail and asking probing questions of the people who run it are due diligence. All board members should be doing the same. Vigilance is especially necessary for prisoners, who tend to have few people looking out for their rights.
Last month, Warden Orlando Harper refused to tell the Post-Gazette the reason for the lockdown or the extent to which he locked down the facility. The county says it has a good reason for keeping the details under wrap, but Ms. Klein and Ms. Wagner were right to press Mr. Harper.
The more questions asked, the more light shined on the jail and the better everyone understands what is happening there. Case in point: After she and Ms. Wagner expressed concern about the number of pregnant inmates, Ms. Klein learned that she had been misreading data on a report. The data referred not to the number of pregnant women but to the number of clinic visits they made. The jail hadn’t been keeping track of the number of pregnant inmates; now, it does. It should have been doing that all along.
The concerns Ms. Klein and Ms. Wagner raised about alternative placements for pregnant inmates remain valid. As a recent report from the University of Pittsburgh indicated, too many people are in the county jail when alternative placements would be better for them and the taxpayers. This is the kind of issue on which board members should be riding herd.
In December, five women filed a lawsuit alleging the jail inappropriately punished them with solitary confinement for minor infractions while they were pregnant. Across the nation, jails and prisons have been criticized for overuse of solitary confinement against various prisoner groups; this is another issue requiring the board’s scrutiny.
Ms. Klein and Ms. Wagner shouldn’t be deterred by their colleagues’ second-guessing. They haven’t set a bad precedent with their vigorous approach to the job. They’ve set a good example.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.