An afternoon encounter between two men and Port Authority police officers rapidly escalated into tragedy Sunday in Wilkinsburg. The district attorney’s office and the Allegheny County Police Department are left with figuring out how a routine matter involving open consumption of alcohol ended in the death of a police dog and the animal’s killer.

Lost in the struggle was K-9 officer Aren, a 5-year-old German shepherd assigned to patrol and explosives, and the man who stabbed Aren to death, Bruce T. Kelley Jr., who had a criminal record of 19 years. Judges along the way also had concerns about his mental health.

This marks the second unnecessary and unwarranted killing of a police dog in two years, and today a sad procession of officers will assemble in honor of Aren in front of a statue erected in remembrance of Rocco, the dog killed in January 2014 during an arrest.

The unusual circumstances began Sunday when two Port Authority officers came upon Kelley and his father, who were drinking in a gazebo next to the Martin Luther King Jr. Busway. According to police, the men attacked the officers, then took off; the officers called for backup.

Advertise with us

Minutes later, other police arrived with Aren and caught up with the men. Officers hit Kelley with a Taser, but his thick coat blocked the electric charge. Aren was let loose on the man, who stabbed the dog in the mouth with a 14-inch knife. Officers shot and killed Kelley.

While nothing can bring back Aren or the man who killed the K-9, this incident poses troubling questions. It goes without saying that Kelley did himself no favors by rejecting police commands from the beginning. As for the officers, was Aren placed at risk unnecessarily? Did police have other ways to subdue Kelley than shooting him dead?

Pittsburgh mourns the loss of another K-9 officer killed in the line of duty and Kelley’s survivors wish this had ended differently as well. What should follow is a probing examination of whether this dreadful outcome, which began with a low-level infraction, could have been avoided.

Meet the Editorial Board.