The design of U.S. Steel’s proposed new headquarters on the former Civic Arena site returns to the city planning commission for review today.

If it hasn’t changed enough to look like a building that belongs in the city, but it still gets the go-ahead, it will fail its legacy challenge. (The Sports and Exhibition Authority and Urban Redevelopment Authority boards have already given preliminary approval.)

Of all places, the Lower Hill deserves an inspiring building. The site is an iconic city crossroads and gateway to a neighborhood that once was as dense and urban as a place could get before losing so much.

At a hearing on March 10, Christine Mondor, principal at Evolve Architecture and chairwoman of the commission, challenged the building’s developer and its architects, saying, "I'm just concerned that it looks like it could be anywhere. It looks like it could be a suburban office building.

Advertise with us

"As a city, we need to ask of our legacy projects design excellence,” she said. “We only got to build the U.S. Steel Tower once, and we did it well. We only got to build PPG once. We only got to build the convention center once.”

The five-story building, designed by Forum Studio for Clayco Realty Group, would be made of steel and glass, as one would expect. But our city’s stewards should expect, and demand, more than this offering.

Ms. Mondor is in a position to be heard, if anyone is listening.

Chris Cedergreen, chairman and principal of Forum Studio, told the commission the firm has constraints, as if fine urban design is automatically too expensive. U.S. Steel is constrained by what it wants to spend on rent to Clayco, which is tied to the Pittsburgh Penguins for 18 years. Ms. Mondor’s concerns were understandable, he said, given Pittsburgh’s emotional connection to U.S. Steel.

That connection is highly applicable to the larger issue.

Advertise with us

What an irony that the corporation that almost defines this city, a superstar of our mighty legacy, would be paying rent in a yawner of a building.

This building should inspire an emotional connection of its own with the public. It should be the kind of building people take visitors to see. It should speak of the place. Many of Pittsburgh’s buildings hit those targets, but too many are suburban copycats.

“Christine is my hero right now,” said Oakland architect Arthur Lubetz. “If architects don’t stand up for architecture, this city is going to be filled with boring, bland and ordinary.”

He said any project on public land that uses public money and tax incentives should be held to a higher standard for the public good. Public officials talk of the city’s vitality and livability, he said, “and architects can help achieve that goal.”

Anne J. Swager, executive director of the American Institute of Architects-Pittsburgh, said the organization believes that when a project involves public land, buildings or funding, "it is acceptable for [oversight] groups to ask for more in the interest of our city and our community."

Advertise with us

She said she thinks the city has “a fairly rigorous development plan approval process” of commissions that include architects and planners. The city has a design review process that precedes the planning commission’s consideration, but it’s an advisory role only.

A lot of boring makes it through these channels.

“We have an art commission,” Mr. Lubetz said. “Why not an architecture commission?”

Fine architecture is a tricky thing to define, but it’s a mistake to say “This is what it should look like” without going further. It should at least look like its designers understand the importance and spirit of the site.

“Good architecture makes people feel good,” Mr. Lubetz said. “It creates positive memories and produces memorable places.”

Advertise with us

Architectural review needs to establish high expectations before a developer hires an architect. Design should not be left up to a hockey team or a corporation. It should not be assumed that fine design is more expensive. Expense also should not be the only factor.

If the difference is excellence, it’s an insult to suggest that these huge budgets can’t be stretched.

It would be a triumph if Pittsburgh’s message to developers were this: “If you want to build in our city, these are our standards. You will be held to them on public land with public money, because we’re no longer just darn grateful anyone wants to invest here. People are competing to invest here. Be better.”

Great design can help Pittsburgh be more than “Most livable.” We should aspire to be “Most alive.”