HAARLEM, The Netherlands —
These were the people we liberated during World War II, who enlisted in the Cold War, agreed to welcome our bases and stayed loyal to us, even as we tried their patience in Vietnam and defied their interests during the 1971 Nixon Shock that, without decent notice, rocked their financial markets.
Now the Americans who created a world market, and profited hugely from it, are determined to live within their vast internal market. America is brandishing the tariff weapon in an effort to build up America, the world they once bent to their will be damned.
Wonder and resentment
That’s why Europe is shaking its head, and its financial fists, in wonder, disbelief, and resentment.
The counting houses of Amsterdam, London, Paris and Frankfurt no longer include their ties with the United States — financial, diplomatic, military — when counting their blessings. They aren’t counting on trade that consists of about $5 billion in goods and services daily with the nations of the European Union, which until now was one of the greatest trade relationships in world history.
Having transformed his government into a combative vanguard of disorder and disruption, Donald Trump is extending disorder and disruption into the continent that spawned the western civilization he says is central to our own culture.
As the United States prepares to mark its semiquincentennial, Americans are about to embark on one of their periodic spasms of worship of two of the greatest products of the European Enlightenment, the 1776 Declaration of Independence and the 1787 Constitution. Those two documents are about to be subjects of national veneration, especially with Mr. Trump in the White House.
The president, no historian, is a devoted enforcer of what we might call a retinoid version of history — one told with an application of anti-blemish wash. A leader who has trumpeted “America First” almost surely will note that America was the first country to embrace freedom as its birthright.
But he is far less likely to emphasize the Enlightenment values of free inquiry, independent thinking, equity and — think back to your 9th grade civics unit on the Constitution — the preservation of the rights of the minority through the separation of powers, checks and balances, and the Bill of Rights, all now under assault from his administration.
America was the first to include them in a structure of government, but we got them from Europe.
A businessman’s offensive
Part of Mr. Trump’s tariff offensive can be traced to his identity as a businessman and his experience in the combative Manhattan real-estate arena and in his other ventures in casinos and the hospitality industry.
William Dean Howells called Mark Twain “the most de-southernized southerner I ever met,” and the president is the least de-businessized politician America ever met. He is a stark contrast to Michael Bloomberg, who was mayor of New York City; Mitt Romney, who was governor of Massachusetts; and Herbert Hoover, George H. W. Bush, and George W. Bush, Mr. Trump’s businessmen-predecessors in the White House.
Only a few European leaders have had business backgrounds. British Prime Minister Neville Chamberlain managed a sisal plantation in the Bahamas. President Emmanuel Macron was an investment banker who worked at Rothschild & Cie Banque. Though both employed crude governmental versions of cost-benefit analysis in their leadership roles, their identity was more political than commercial.
While American presidents have often been described as “chief executives,” Mr. Trump governs as a CEO — a subtle but significant difference. This corresponds to an ongoing transformation in the character of American government. A 2017 Brookings Institution study found that the number of members of the House of Representatives with business or banking experience more than doubled in the 15 years beginning in 2001.
Sitting in America’s C-Suite, Mr. Trump emphasizes his celebrated art of the deal even as he employs artless negotiating tactics. The opening gambit in his battle with what he characterizes as “totally unacceptable” European trade practices barriers was a set of 50% tariffs, now postponed to July 9 pending negotiations.
“The European Union, which was formed for the primary purpose of taking advantage of the United States on TRADE, has been very difficult to deal with,” Mr. Trump wrote in a Truth Social sentence that likely would not receive honors grades at the Wharton School at the University of Pennsylvania that is his alma mater.
Mr. Trump also has claimed that in trade relationships with the United States, the European Union has “treated us very badly over the years.”
A different relation
Let’s pause for a moment to acknowledge that relations between allies are often difficult. Though there’s substantial overlap between the the European Union and NATO, and despite the fact that the United States and Europe share values, outlook and a common modern history, there always are strains among allies.
But the relation is different now. In 1971, European waters were roiled by Mr. Nixon’s unilateral cancellation of direct convertibility of the dollar to gold and the then-unprecedented imposition of 25% trade barriers on some European products.
Ralf Dahrendorf, an external trade and relations commissioner for the Common Market (the predecessor to the EU), said the Nixon decisions “respond to American self‐interest without evident regard to the interest of others who are and will continue to be closely allied with the United States.” No European leader would say “will continue” today.
David M. Shribman, the former executive editor of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, is a scholar-in-residence at Carnegie Mellon University and a columnist for the Post-Gazette. His previous column was “America is losing her friends.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.