HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr.’s father swept into Lawrence, Kan., 57 years ago this month to give a campaign speech. It was just his third day as a 1968 presidential candidate and he clearly was trying out themes for his challenge to President Lyndon B. Johnson, who was still a candidate for re-election.
Though still a very tentative work-in-progress as a contender for the White House, Mr. Kennedy’s remarks offer a time-capsule from another period of great divisions, another point when important American values were at stake, when the character of the country was in the balance.
It was a time very much like our own, and yet, as his comments will demonstrate, also a time very different from ours.
The contrasts
The contrasts are apparent from the very first words of the Kennedy remarks. He, arguably a member of the 20th century’s greatest Democratic family, began by saluting Kansas’s Senators James B. Pearson and Frank Carlson.
Both men were Republicans. His comments about the two are the functional equivalent of Donald Trump visiting Nevada and saluting Senators Catherine Cortez Masto and Jacky Rosen, two Democrats. Donald Trump is more likely to be hit by the asteroid 024YR4, apparently a threat to strike earth in 2032, than do that.
Mr. Kennedy went on to speak about the issues of the day — the continuing war in Vietnam, the racial divide, the alienation of the youth who comprised his audience at the University of Kansas. He was at times lighthearted and at at times heavily reflective. He thought the country was on the wrong track, a view Americans share today by about a two-to-one margin, according to a recent Gallup Poll.
Read More
The senator from New York lingered on education, giving a thoughtful defense of the values of a university. He then delivered two sentences that you will not hear from the current occupant of the White House.
They went this way: “If our colleges and universities do not breed men who riot, who rebel, who attack life with all the youthful vision and vigor, then there is something wrong with our colleges. The more riots that come out of our college campuses, the better the world for tomorrow.”
He knew that his listeners thought that those words were his, and then he revealed the true origin. “Despite all the accusations against me, those words were not written by me,” he said. “They were written by that notorious seditionist, William Allen White.”
The name William Allen White was well-known to that audience. He was the late editor of the Emporia Gazette, a small but beloved newspaper, and there was no more revered figure in Kansas than Mr. White, who had died in 1944. (His name now graces the university’s distinguished School of Journalism and Mass Communications.)
The roster of Americans who made the pilgrimage to Red Rocks, as the White home was known, included such radicals as Calvin Coolidge, Herbert Hoover, and the widow of the financier J.P. Morgan. Commentary Magazine once described Mr. White as an editor and activist who “consistently served the most reactionary elements in the Republican Party.”
Different playbooks
And yet here was the Sage of Emporia, arguing that, on campus, “there must be clash and if youth hasn’t enough force or fervor to produce the clash the world grows stale and stagnant and sour in decay.” This is not part of the Trump playbook, and it won’t be part of a Trump speech.
The following RFK passage might, however, be part of a Trump speech: “The fact is, that men have lost confidence in themselves, in each other, it is confidence which has sustained us so much in the past.”
That lack of confidence helped fuel the Trump campaigns, and Mr. Kennedy explained, as the president might, that “hundreds of communities and millions of citizens are looking for their answers, to force and repression and private gun stocks — so that we confront our fellow citizen across impossible barriers of hostility and mistrust.”
But Mr. Kennedy went on to say, “I don’t believe that we have to accept that. I don’t believe that it’s necessary in the United States of America. I think that we can work together — I don’t think that we have to shoot at each other, to beat each other, to curse each other and criticize each other, I think that we can do better in this country.” This language of accommodation rather than division is the divergence point between Mr. Trump and Mr. Kennedy.
And yet both RFK Jr.’s father and the 47th president share a certain perspective on the country. These Kennedy comments could easily be cited by Mr. Trump: “I have seen proud men in the hills of Appalachia, who wish only to work in dignity, but they cannot, for the mines are closed and their jobs are gone and no one — neither industry, nor labor, nor government — has cared enough to help.”
A decent respect
The passage that follows might be provocative for Mr. Trump, eager to disrupt longstanding American alliances, from Canada to NATO: “From the beginning our proudest boast has been the promise of Jefferson, that we, here in this country would be the best hope of mankind.”
But now, “we wonder if we still hold a decent respect for the opinions of mankind and whether the opinion maintained a decent respect for us or whether like Athens of old, we will forfeit sympathy and support, and ultimately our very security, in the single-minded pursuit of our own goals and our own objectives.”
Mr. Kennedy’s speech has not grown old. The president should read it.
David M. Shribman’s previous column was “Donald Trump is two presidents in one.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.