Donald Trump is a singular figure in United States political history — an elitist at war with the country’s elite, the beneficiary of the American commercial system who is resentful of the institutions that created the nation’s economic power, a president who is reshaping American history despite his vast ignorance of it.
And yet in a way, Mr. Trump is not a singular figure at all, but in fact two presidents in one, possessed of irreconcilable ideas and impulses. Here is a look at the two Trumps and the contradictions between them.
The two Trumps
• He wants a deal with Ukraine/He wants to deal Ukraine away. These two antithetical Trumps were on vivid display during last month’s Oval Office spectacle with Ukraine President Volodymyr Zelensky. The session was called to seal a deal on Ukraine’s vital mineral resources. By the climax of the meeting, it was clear the president was willing to make a peace without Ukraine’s involvement or approbation.
In recent days, Mr. Trump has indicated he may lift the pause on intelligence sharing with Ukraine. Where that leaves the relations between the United States and Ukraine is impossible to know, as is the role of Russia in the emerging situation.
• The administration is convulsed in, and is spawning, chaos/ The chaos is not accidental, it’s planned. No one can dispute that the mass firings, agency shutterings, swift and dramatic alterations in policy and moves begging for court tests has done anything but sow chaos in a country that, as the lone superpower, might ordinarily crave stability.
But much of this chaos is in the Trump governing script, set out in remarkable detail by the Project 2025 of the Heritage Foundation and the America First Policy Institute. If the Trump manifestos were student papers, they’d be guilty of plagiarism.
• Mr. Trump is an unusually charming public figure/Mr. Trump is a dangerous demagogue. It is difficult to recall a mainstream political figure who commands unswerving devotion from his base who at the same time has spawned an opposition united in its deep disdain of him, frustrated by its apparent powerlessness but displaying signs of resistance.
• Mr. Trump knows exactly what he is doing/He doesn’t know what he is doing. Yes, the Trump team is following the libretto from the two think tanks. But in many ways it is moving without knowledge of, or respect for, the consequences.
That explains the aggressive shuttering of offices and firing of officials — and then the quiet reopening and re-hiring of them. These include government employees managing the response to bird flu, assuring the safety of the country’s nuclear arsenal, and researchers working on food and medical-device safety.
For and against business
• Mr. Trump is defying the business interests he cares about dearly/He is listening to business leaders and lobbyists. A little of both. Very few business leaders agree that broad tariffs, a blunt tool, work to the advantage of the domestic economy and believe, instead, that they threaten a recession. Either purposely or inadvertently, Mr. Trump breathed air into that notion with his comments that there may be a short-term price for the changes he is bringing to the economy.
At the same time, as entrepreneur and tycoon, Mr. Trump respects above all people who have made enormous sums of money or who control powerful American corporations. He also is not immune to the entreaties of important interest groups in states and regions that provide the base of his support.
An excellent example: potash, which is employed as fertilizer to stabilize agricultural crops and restore soil fertility. Heeding the pleas of farmers and rural lawmakers, Mr. Trump reduced the tariffs to 10% on potash not covered by the 2019 US/Canada/Mexico trade agreement he signed.
Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins described the Trump decision as “a critical step in helping farmers manage and secure key input costs at the height of planting season while reinforcing long-term agricultural trade relations.”
A disruptor, a reformer
• Mr. Trump is disrupting the world order on purpose/His actions only give the impression that he seeks a wholesale overhaul of the world order. This is the most complex element of Mr. Trump’s split identity. The president’s disrespect for the foundation stones of the post-World War II era is well known, with special enmity for the United Nations (and associated organizations such as the World Health Organization, United Nations Human Rights Council, and UNESCO, the educational and cultural organization). He’s skeptical of NATO but his intentions about the alliance the United States created in 1949 aren’t clear.
One indication of whether he is seeking a wholesale re-evaluation of the American security profile toward Russia and away from traditional allies may come in the third week of July. Under a 1959 law signed by a Republican president, Dwight Eisenhower, every president has been required to declare that period as “Captive Nations Week,” a clear jibe at the Soviet Union and its survivor state, Russia. Mr. Trump did so all four years of his first term.
Mr. Trump’s running battle with Canada’s Justin Trudeau now is at an end, and the emergence of an accomplished central banker, Mark Carney, as the leader of the Liberal Party and its standard-bearer in the coming election may change the character of the American relationship with its northern neighbor.
Mr. Trump had no respect for Mr. Trudeau, whom he regarded as a callow boy trading on his father’s fame and name. Mr. Carney is a different figure altogether, difficult to dismiss — and perhaps the lever on which a new Trump outlook and set of policy options could emerge. It has happened before.
David M. Shribman, the former executive editor of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, is a scholar-in-residence at Carnegie Mellon University and a columnist for the Post-Gazette. His previous column was “The courts will decide. Trump might ignore them.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.