Donald Trump could be ahead right now, even with Kamala Harris the new Democratic candidate. He needed only to change himself after coming within an inch or two of dying. It would have been a transformation one could believe.
Having come so close to death — to oblivion or the next world — he could feel in a pit of your stomach way that his time on earth grows shorter every second, and won’t stretch many years into the future, and decided to spend it as a different man. A better man, or at least a man who looked like a good man to more people. He could have been “presidential,” concerned for the nation, including his enemies, seeking unity.
Trump talked “presidential,” and his supporters talked that way, for a little bit. It seemed possible that he’d really changed. He did almost die, after all.
He could have changed
I think that would have kept him ahead of Harris, and given him an advantage among the small but significant group of people who don’t like him but agree with him more than with the Democrats, often a lot more, and who were kept from supporting him because of the way he acts. I think more voters than the pollsters know would be relieved to have a reason to vote for Trump and Vance.
Then he went back to being the Donald Trump we all know. He could be ahead right now, if only he could do what Robert F. Kennedy Sr. did in 1968. But he can’t change, or won’t. That’s not really surprising. Priests and doctors have told me how rarely coming close to death changes people.
Nearly dying doesn’t change many of us for a reason Aristotle saw 2500 years ago: We make ourselves by the lives we live, the choices we make, the kindnesses and cruelties we commit, the truths and lies we tell — becoming more solid, substantial even, thereby capable of more, but also much stiffer, less malleable, less able to be different people.
Read More
A man Trump’s age is the man he made himself to be, his character set in concrete. He can’t stop being the Donald Trump we know, even when change could bring him the presidency he craves. In that, I should say, he’s a man like the rest of us, and most of us have less justification for pointing the finger than we think we do. But we’re also not running for president.
Kennedy unlike Trump
Like Trump, Bobby Kennedy faced a major blow to his campaign for president, because like Trump he’d based it on running against an increasingly unpopular sitting president. He needed to gather a huge number of supporters and win primaries to convince his party’s backroom establishment to give him the nomination over Lyndon B. Johnson.
A very long shot, but the only chance he had. And Johnson was vulnerable, particularly over his conduct of the Vietnam war, which Kennedy had come to oppose, after being one of the people in his brother’s administration who got the country into it.
Then Johnson, having won the New Hampshire primary by too few votes, and fearing he wouldn’t survive another term, shocked the country by dropping out of the race. He too was succeeded as the Democratic candidate by his vice president, Hubert Humphrey, though Humphrey didn’t gain the nomination as quickly as Harris did.
But Bobby Kennedy could change in a way that sustained him when he lost the best way to win the presidency and also made him a man other people would vote for. He had two causes — in addition to Vietnam, which wasn’t going away — racial reconciliation and care for the very poor. And they moved him in a way he had not been moved when he was a younger, more ambitious and calculating, politician.
In 1967, he went to the Mississippi Delta with other congressmen and visited Black sharecroppers in their homes. “In a windowless shack reeking of mildew and urine he came upon a mother and six children,” Thurston Clarke writes in “The Last Campaign.”
“A malnourished two-year-old girl with a distended stomach lay sprawled on the floor, surrounded by roaches and playing listlessly with a grain of rice. He knelt down and began stroking her hair and murmuring, ‘Hello... Hi, baby...’ Realizing that she was too weak with hunger to respond, he gathered her into his arms and began rocking and kissing her.” He responded the same way to a little boy, this time crying.
He was for real
Marian Wright of the NAACP Legal Defense Fund was with him (reporters were excluded). She said she could not have done that and saw then that Kennedy was “for real.”
Clarke writes: “Kennedy’s active moral imagination meant that his response to suffering like this went beyond pity and outrage. It meant, according to Cesar Chavez, that Kennedy ‘could see things through the eyes of the poor.’” He could see himself living their lives and could imagine his children living their lives.
I think it was his moral imagination that made Bobby Kennedy capable of changing, because it made him respond to real people with real concern. Empathy kept him from getting too stiff. We need more people in politics like him.
David Mills’ previous column was “Pittsburgh, Israel and what our government does in our name with our money.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.