Editor’s note: As an experiment, columnist David Shribman wrote his column as usual and then submitted a prompt to ChatGPT and bid the artificial-intelligence provider to prepare a column on the same theme. What follows are Mr. Shribman’s column, the ChatGPT column and an assessment of the experiment by Mr. Shribman.
MONTREAL — They are the stereo speakers, unplugged.
In Washington, House Speaker Kevin McCarthy was toppled by House rebels who punished him for consorting with Democrats in avoiding a government shutdown and for failing to press for deeper cuts in federal spending in what Representative Andy Biggs of Arizona, one of Mr. McCarthy’s most ardent critics, called in the House debate “wasteful, duplicative programs.”
In Ottawa, House Speaker Anthony Rota lost his position after he invited Yaroslav Hunka to Parliament during the visit of Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy, celebrated him as a hero, and stood in front of the chamber while Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and Mr. Zelenskyy applauded him vigorously. Mr. Hunka, 98 years old, turned out to be a member of the 14th Waffen Grenadier Division of the SS.
Two North American countries, two House speakers, two lessons in civics.
The first is clear: Don’t fête Nazis. The second should have been apparent from the start: Don’t give your most ardent critics the weapon — in this case a House provision allowing a single dissident lawmaker to move to declare the speakership “vacant” — to jeopardize your leadership.
The fact that these two maxims of our time were not obvious were individual mistakes, not institutional flaws.
But in the American case, the crisis that enveloped the speakership was a symbol of a more wide-reaching, more troublesome phenomenon: national disunity that has prompted political dysfunction. The irony is that Mr. McCarthy — sometimes clawing for power, often craven in its pursuit — was toppled for doing the two things that have been missing in Washington for a decade: seeking bipartisan agreement and putting narrow political interests aside for the broader national good.
This occurred over last weekend when, with the assistance of 209 Democrats, he maneuvered through the House legislation that prevented a government shutdown. In doing so, he inflamed the very Republican rebels who have held him hostage and who made political roulette — a single bullet of defiance from one of the critics whose satisfaction comes from never being satisfied — the price of the speakership for which he so yearned.
“I have no regret for standing up for governance over grievance,” Mr. McCarthy said after losing his gavel. In a press conference only slightly less treacly than Richard Nixon’s bitter farewell to the Sacramento press corps after losing the 1962 California gubernatorial race, he said his goal was to “build coalitions and find solutions.”
He did in fact build a coalition and find a solution to a national challenge over the weekend, and he did it with the full knowledge that he was courting not only Democrats but also his own demise. He did it, moreover, by defying not only the hardline conservatives in his caucus but also by defying the expectations of the era — and the expectations Washington had of Mr. McCarthy himself .
“What I am asking, Republicans and Democrats alike, put your partisanship away,” he said at the time. “Focus on the American public.” This language was not part of the McCarthy portfolio. Neither the rebels who controlled his destiny nor the Democrats who reviled him for his fecklessness thought he had the courage to do it.
That’s because Mr. McCarthy’s focus always had been on survival — surviving the grueling 15 ballots that led to his fragile speakership, surviving the taunts from the rebels whose demands became central to Republican rule in the chamber rather than peripheral to it, surviving the final challenge to his leadership.
The price he paid for surviving insured that in the end he ultimately could not survive.
In our fraught era, we’ve grown accustomed to split-screen political drama: Republican presidential contenders engage in a debate and former President Donald Trump grants an interview to Tucker Carlson. The candidates gather for a second debate and Mr. Trump speaks about the perils facing auto workers on the picket line in Detroit.
But seldom has the contrast between two screens been as dramatic as they were Tuesday, when, at the very same time, the Canadian parliament was selecting a new speaker of the House of Commons and the American House of Representatives was repelling its speaker from office.
The Canadian action was crisp, full of celebration and good cheer, the anxieties of the embarrassment in front of Mr. Zelenskyy galloping into the past. The American scene more nearly resembled a bloodletting, a televised political assassination preceded by a confusing procedural vote, agonizing to witness.
Part of the contrast relates to the differences in the two speakerships.
The position that Greg Fergus assumes as the first Black speaker in Canada is nonpartisan, so much so that the picture that emerged from Ottawa was Mr. Fergus being escorted around Commons with his arms locked on one side with Prime Minister Trudeau and on the other with Conservative leader Pierre Poilievre. The Canadians fight as fiercely on Parliament Hill as the Americans do on Capitol Hill, but their speaker is more traffic cop than enforcer.
“These are very different roles,” said Pierre Martin, a Université de Montréal political scientist. “The Canadian speaker is supposed to step away from the action, to be more as a referee. The American speaker combines the notion of chairing the House with a very partisan role of making sure the majority agenda is pushed through the Congress. The Canadian speaker has no role in politics per se—though the government counts on the speaker to make the parliament run smoothly.”
Congress, too, once ran smoothly; indeed previous speakers prided themselves on running a legislative body with far more efficiency than the Senate. The Founders, who thought of almost everything, didn’t contemplate what occurred after sunset Tuesday: a House with big talkers but no speaker.
The American speakership is specifically mentioned in the Constitution, with the office intended to render its occupant the guardian of the institution, the speaker of the entire House, not of just the majority.
“But the expectations for speakers have become looking out for the majority party’s interests,” said Sarah Binder, a George Washington University political scientist. “These functions aren’t typically the same.”
In this era of intense partisanship, the majority parties do not want to look to the other party for votes. Left to their own devices they would legislate with only the support from their party alone. That means passing legislation with only the votes of one party. This past week demonstrated that that impulse and that inclination are doomed to fail.
THE WINDS OF POLITICAL CHANGE: McCarthy’s fall and Canada’s surprising shift
Here is the prompt for ChatGPT and its response: Write a 1069 word essay in the style of David Shribman on the toppling of House Speaker Kevin McCarthy and the selection of a new speaker of the House of Commons in Canada.
In the annals of North American politics, few spectacles are as captivating as the ascent and descent of political leaders. Recent events have illustrated this phenomenon in sharp relief. In the United States, the sudden and unforeseen toppling of House Speaker Kevin McCarthy shocked many. Meanwhile, to the north, the House of Commons in Canada witnessed the selection of a new speaker—a moment significant not only for its effect on Canadian governance but also for the broader narrative it tells about the evolution of politics in our two countries.
For those of us who have spent a lifetime studying the ebbs and flows of the political landscape, these moments, while not unprecedented, are always enlightening. They force us to pause and reflect on the deeper currents shaping the course of our democracies.
In the American context, Kevin McCarthy’s fall from grace has been likened to the Shakespearean tragedies where ambition and hubris collide. McCarthy, who once commanded the loyalty of his party and stood firm against opposition currents, faced a confluence of internal dissension, grassroots disaffection, and evolving national sentiment that proved too strong to resist. But the story is more nuanced than that. McCarthy’s decline can also be seen as a symptom of a deeper malaise within the Republican Party—a party grappling with its identity in the post-Trump era.
Where once McCarthy was praised for his ability to bridge the divide between establishment Republicans and the Trumpian base, in the end, it seemed he could fully satisfy neither. As the GOP navigated contentious issues—from election integrity to the direction of conservative policy—McCarthy found himself at the center of a whirlwind, one that eventually uprooted him from his cherished position.
If McCarthy’s fall was a tale of political tumult and turbulence, then the story unfolding in Canada is one of reinvigoration and reimagining. Canada’s parliamentary system, though distinct from the American congressional model, offers its own set of challenges and opportunities. The role of the Speaker of the House of Commons, traditionally a figure who must navigate the choppy waters of party politics to maintain order and decorum, has become even more pivotal in recent years.
As Canada faced its own set of crises—from a resurgent Quebec separatism to the challenges posed by indigenous rights and climate change—the Speaker’s gavel has come to symbolize more than just parliamentary procedure. It stands for the hope of unity, the aspiration for consensus, and the desire for a politics that transcends the polarities of the day.
In this context, the selection of the new speaker represents not just a change of guard, but also a potential paradigm shift. The emphasis during the selection process on bipartisan cooperation, on elevating voices from diverse backgrounds, and on creating a more inclusive and deliberative legislative process speaks to the aspirations of many Canadians. It also suggests a willingness to chart a different course—a course that recognizes the importance of tradition but is not beholden to it; one that values consensus but does not fear robust debate.
Yet, while the developments in the US and Canada may seem distinct, they are, in many ways, two sides of the same coin. Both speak to the challenges faced by mature democracies in the 21st century: How to maintain relevance in an era of rapid change? How to ensure that political institutions reflect the will and aspirations of their people? And how to navigate the treacherous waters of polarization and division?
Both countries are at a crossroads. In the US, the post-McCarthy era presents an opportunity for the Republican Party to redefine itself and for the broader political system to seek new pathways of collaboration and consensus. The challenge is to find a balance between the passion of grassroots movements and the pragmatism required for effective governance.
In Canada, the new Speaker will have the task of steering the House of Commons through what promises to be a period of transformative change. With issues like climate change, reconciliation with indigenous communities, and the challenges of a post-pandemic world on the horizon, the Speaker’s role will be more crucial than ever. The hope is that this new leadership will bring a fresh perspective and a commitment to the values that have always defined Canadian politics: moderation, collaboration, and a commitment to the common good.
In conclusion, while the toppling of Kevin McCarthy and the selection of a new speaker in Canada might seem like disparate events, they are deeply interconnected. They serve as poignant reminders of the fragility and resilience of democratic institutions. They underscore the importance of leadership, not just in terms of wielding power but in guiding nations through times of uncertainty and change.
As David Shribman might have mused, politics is as much about the moments that shape us as it is about the decisions we make. It’s about the stories we tell and the lessons we draw from them. And as the dust settles on these recent events, it’s clear that both the US and Canada are poised for a new chapter—one that promises both challenges and opportunities. In this ever-evolving dance of democracy, the only certainty is change itself. And as history has shown, it’s not the change that defines us, but how we respond to it.
David Shribman reacts:
It is a frightful thing to see a machine capture your approach and writing style, and to do in less than 120 seconds what took me several hours—television viewing, telephone interviewing, actual writing time—to produce. In truth, it spooked me. And scared me about the future of human-produced news analysis.
In the ChatGPT column I shuddered as I saw several of the kind of phrases and approaches I use, and I read in wonder at some of the illuminating ChatGPT insights, many of which I admired. For some of them I could say, as writers sometimes do, “I wish I’d written that.” And though the ChatGPT version leans on easy if not lazy rhetorical devices and cliches—a chilling reminder that a machine suggested that those crutches were part of my own style — though its characterization of the role of the Speaker of the Canadian House of Commons is not quite right, I have to concede that the AI version overall is an admirable piece of work.
But remember this: The writer who thought of combining and comparing the Canadian and American legislative bodies—the essence of the column, the part that took imagination—was not a computer. Chalk one up for the human, chastened as he might be.
David Shribman is the former executive editor of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.