FORT LAUDERDALE, Fla. — The vital primary in this battleground state that has provided a vital margin in two of the five elections this century is a little more than a week away, and already voters here are confronting a new political reality.
It was only three months ago that House Democrats, knowing that the Republican-controlled Senate would resist their impassioned arguments and their passel of arguments, impeached Donald Trump. With an eye on history and the stain their action would put on the president, they hoped to cut Mr. Trump down to size.
Instead the 45th president is living large.
Large enough to visit Democratic primary states like this one to taunt putative rivals. Large enough to defy Congress and complete a wall across the Mexican border. Large enough to intervene in Justice Department proceedings. Large enough even to alienate his greatest Cabinet ally, Attorney General William Barr.
Perhaps even large enough to weather the storm created by Typhoon Coronavirus (and its attendant economic ravages) to defeat whomever the Democrats run against him in the November election.
Less than three decades ago, Time magazine put on its front a minuscule picture of Bill Clinton with the piercing cover title “The Incredibly Shrinking President.” That 1993 edition of the magazine came to symbolize the diminution of the presidency in American civic life.
Read More
Now Americans are contemplating an incredibly expanding presidency.
“Trump’s repeated efforts to push through his agenda continues the march of expanding presidential power we have seen in recent presidencies,” said Shirley Anne Warshaw, a presidential scholar at Gettysburg College. “But what separates Trump from his recent predecessors is the complete disregard for the rule of law.”
The prospect of impeachment terrified Lyndon Johnson, who as a result dared not stray from his path in Vietnam. The impending impeachment of Richard Nixon sent the embattled president on an alcoholic bender and a diversionary-move trip to the Middle East. The real impeachment of Bill Clinton, only two decades ago, led the humbled chief executive to assert his sorrow, express his apology and redouble his determination to pass his agenda.
“I want to say again to the American people how profoundly sorry I am for what I said and did to trigger these events, and the great burden they have imposed on the Congress and on the American people,” Mr. Clinton said.
Mr. Trump, in the identical situation, said he was experiencing a “day of celebration.”
But the Trump mix of what he regarded as his exoneration and what he declared was “celebration” brought on a new burst of aggressiveness — and new challenges to the centuries-old balance of power between the legislative and executive branches.
The president’s assertiveness on his border wall is a prime example. By diverting millions of dollars Congress appropriated for the military to the wall, Mr. Trump is contributing to what must now be regarded as the incredible shrinking legislative branch.
Other presidents have struck at the power of the purse that the Founding Fathers placed squarely in the hands of the Congress; Mr. Nixon, for example, was a pioneer in withholding spending that Congress expressly approved.
But the Nixon action — which bore the term “impoundment” — was different in tone and spirit. He failed to carry out the wishes of Congress, to be sure, but in bridling what he called the “credit-card Congress,” Mr. Nixon could cite the discretion of the executive in dispersing funds appropriated by Congress.
Mr. Trump’s initiative has taken the Nixon act to a new level. He can cite national security; that is a handy presidential rationale, used by Dwight Eisenhower, for example, as his explanation for building the interstate highway system that of course has been used primarily by civilians, business and vacationers.
But both houses of Congress have immigration and border security panels, and by any reasonable reading the wall comes under their remits.
That is why Republicans joined Democrats in decrying Mr. Trump’s action. Though GOP lawmakers defended the president in the impeachment trial that followed the House action, lawmakers of both parties jealously guard the functional prerogatives of the Congress, with spending at the top of those centuries-old rights.
The founders may have created the balance of powers but a series of presidents and lawmakers have created a swing in that balance.
After the Civil War, the balance alternated between a president, Andrew Johnson, who had his own (lenient) ideas about how to treat the devastated South, and the Radical Republicans who wanted to punish the defeated Confederacy and extend new rights to the former enslaved. That resulted in the impeachment of the 17th president, who was saved from removal from office by a single vote in the Senate.
In the aftermath of the assassination of John F. Kennedy, Lyndon Johnson, a former Senate majority leader, held sway over Congress and pressed through massive Great Society domestic spending initiatives. But once opposition to the Vietnam War gathered force, Congress reasserted itself.
The balance wobbled so dramatically during the Nixon administration that followed Johnson’s that by the beginning of the president’s second term the liberal historian Arthur M. Schlesinger would publish a book called “The Imperial Presidency.” Congress responded that same year with the War Powers Act that sharply curtailed the president’s flexibility in projecting American force abroad.
Now Mr. Trump is throwing new challenges to the balance of power — and to its stepchild, the separation of powers. By expressing outrage at last month’s sentencing of Roger Stone, his occasional adviser, he is threatening to wield the power of the pardon.
That power is specifically granted to him in the Constitution. But a swift expression of it in the wake of Mr. Stone’s guilty verdict would create new tensions with the other branch of the government: the judiciary.
That is the branch that could adjudicate such a pardon in relation to the Constitutional provision giving the president “power to grant reprieves and pardons for offense against the United States, except in cases of impeachment.” The Stone matter grows directly out of matters considered during the Trump impeachment. The Constitution does not grant the president room to grant such pardons if he is impeached but not convicted.
Even without considering the Stone matter, Mr. Trump has expanded the powers of the executive. A president who does not shrink from expressing his impulses does not make for a shrinking presidency.
David M. Shribman is a former and now emeritus executive editor of the Post-Gazette and a nationally syndicated columnist. He is a visiting professor at McGill University in Montreal (dshribman@post-gazette.com).





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.