The party that wanted to legally separate particular people from everyone else, to their harm, had been working very hard to get their way and now was working harder than ever, said the man just nominated to run for the U.S. Senate against a powerful incumbent, who was among the party working to harm those particular people, though a relatively moderate voice when moderation was, as the new candidate thought, failure.

The forces of slavery wouldn’t stop, and those who opposed them couldn’t stop, “until a crisis shall have been reached, and passed,” Abraham Lincoln said, speaking to the Illinois Republican Convention in 1858, two years before he was elected president and less than three years before the Confederacy fired on Fort Sumter and began the Civil War.

Then (quoting Jesus) Lincoln gave one of his most famous lines: “A house divided against itself cannot stand. I believe this government cannot endure, permanently half slave and half free. I do not expect the Union to be dissolved — I do not expect the house to fall — but I do expect it will cease to be divided. It will become all one thing or all the other.”

An impossible division

His words, on what would be his 217th birthday, apply to us — in an attenuated way, but enough to worry about. America isn’t a house divided in the same way it was before the Civil War, when the division ran through the nation’s institutions in a way that could not be fixed without risking further and maybe final division. But we could get there.

Advertise with us

In Lincoln’s judgment, America would be a country without the horror of slavery or a country characterized by the horror of slavery. Even a republic divided into states able to choose most of their own laws and policies couldn’t survive so deep a difference between visions of what today we would call human rights and human dignity.

Why was this so? Slavery pressed upon each state an insoluble problem, that could not be answered with a compromise either side could accept. Either an enslaved person became free when he entered a free state or he remained the legal property of the enslaver, who had the right to go get him and drag him back into slavery.

It also required a definite commitment neither side could allow. Slavery must be either allowed in every new state and territory or banned in them all. The national government letting each choose would institutionalize the belief that slavery didn’t matter much, a trick the abolitionists saw. Partisans knew that choice would settle what kind of nation America would be from then on.

An inevitable division

Looking back, we can see the house was inevitably going to divide over slavery. The founders don’t seem to have seen it, even the ones who disliked slavery and worried about its effects. They — being mostly enslavers themselves — were too used to it, unable to see how bad the institution was, at best feeling it was “not optimal,” as we might say.

No one seems to have felt the burning indignation against slavery so many people came to feel a few decades later. Or that we feel today, when it’s easy to feel but no less true for that.

Advertise with us

They believed, I think, that the house would stand as long as Americans believed in some idea of America that transcended the divisive issues.

In his farewell address, given in 1794 at the end of his second term, George Washington declared that when every American felt “an immediate and particular interest in union,” everyone together would enjoy “greater strength, greater resource, proportionably greater security from external danger ... and, what is of inestimable value, they must derive from union an exemption from those broils and wars between themselves.”

He was wrong, as Lincoln knew when he spoke just 62 years later. Ideals like “union” don’t overcome self-interest, like an economy based on slavery. They don’t restrain the baser human passions that run riot in political life, like the desire to lie and slander and to get revenge. They can’t stop “broils and wars” when people have reason to fight.

Our dividing house

America isn’t where it was in 1858. We’re not at the point where a practical matter that can’t be compromised forces division. But the house is dividing.

Many people are angrier and crueller than they were, and there are many more of very angry and cruel people than before. The polls show people beginning to bunch at the poles with fewer in the middle. The same is true for politicians, though one party has run harder for the extreme than the other.

Advertise with us

A disturbing number of people I’ve known for a long time are now genuinely ugly about people on the other side, in a way I would have thought impossible for them. They’re cultural canaries in a coal mine. They just don’t criticize their ideological opponents, as they might have done before, they set themselves against them as enemies of the good, the true and the beautiful.

Now, I understand it, because I can see the impulses in myself and in friends. It can be a lot of fun to hate people when you can tell yourself you’re on God’s or America’s or enlightenment’s side. And as a bonus, you become part of a team or family of people who think just like you and make the world so much simpler.

What to do? Another of Jesus’ sayings that Lincoln did not quote bears on life in a dividing house. “No man can serve two masters: for either he will hate the one, and love the other; or else he will hold to the one, and despise the other.”

We all have to choose between two masters, whom we might call the God of love and the God of hatred. I think most human beings try to serve both, and that most people prefer the first but can’t give up the second. That God offers the goodies.

But as Lincoln understood about our nation, eventually we’ll all become one or the other. And then the house divides.

David Mills’s previous column was “Illegal immigrants make America money.”