”It’s like the place that time forgot,” the guy at a table behind me said. “Anyone can come in and have a good time.” I’m sitting at the bar at our local place, a classic dive bar, to get dinner and watch the Penguins beat the Capitals (because the Capitals deserve to be beaten, not like the Cowboys and the Yankees deserve to be beaten, but still, beaten).
The same people
The others at the table agree, comparing my place to a place in the next town down the river. There, one says, “It’s a different crowd every night,” and she doesn’t like that. “Here you see the same people.”
The other place had once been a bar known for drug-dealing. New owners sent it upscale, putting in plate glass windows so people could see inside, adding plants and IPAs and a menu written in colored chalks on a chalkboard.
Going upscale, it’s no longer a dive bar, not even really a townie bar, but the kind of place people choose for an evening out. Our local place remains the kind of place you go to because it’s your local place.
It’s the default, if you want a local place, not a destination. Your place, because you’re a local and you show up. The regulars, one bartender used to say, think of it as their living rooms.
But it’s also an endangered institution, and that’s bad for America.
An endangered institution
One of the reasons they’re endangered is economic. The bars survive on small margins and don’t have great reserves. Rising prices hurt them in a way they don’t hurt the chain places whose character was invented by a consulting firm.
But the reasons are mostly cultural. Fewer and fewer people drink, 20-somethings especially. And many who do, don’t go to a place whose best draft beer is Yuengling.
Ours is a smoking bar, like most dive bars, and a lot fewer people smoke than in the past, and a lot fewer will tolerate breathing in other people’s smoke.
And of course a lot of people won’t go into a place like ours, even if it weren’t smoking, because they look down on the people there. I’ve gotten enough shocked “You go there?” comments from people in the affluent boroughs up the river to know how strong class boundaries and class snobbery remain.
Most importantly, Americans grow further and further apart, as more and more stay out of intimate shared spaces, like townie bars. As a widely read article in The Atlantic in January put it, “self-imposed solitude might just be the most important social fact of the 21st century in America.”
When most Americans go out, they go out by themselves or with people from their circles, for a transaction, a good meal, not to join a community. Then they go home.
A lot of us don’t talk to others much, except to people like us. That’s bad.
A place to talk
The first article I wrote for the Post-Gazette, written before I came here as an editor, was about my local place. The editor titled it “A good place to be.”
So I was cheered to see this month on the conservative site Unherd a defense of the dive bar. The dive bar, Ryan Zickgraf wrote, is defined by “a no-bull[expletive] working-class refusal of curation: inexpensive drinks, worn furniture, mismatched stools, and a clientele shaped by the neighborhood rather than what’s trendy. Dive bars feel lived in rather than staged.”
They are places, and among the last places, “where Americans are not sorted by taste, income, or identity before they walk through the door to ask for a shot or a beer.”
And, I would add, one of the few places very different Americans can meet as equals, talk as friends and learn how other people see the world. That makes it a good place to be.
One of my best friends at my local place holds political views pretty much the opposite of mine, and I’ve learned how they make sense to him, given who he is and the life he’s had. That is, what he knows that I don’t.
I’ve learned, from Greg and others, how much my confidence in political institutions, even qualified as it is, reflects my privileged position, and what good reasons they have to distrust the elites.
They see, for example, the elite drive to forgive school loans as the privileged serving the privileged, because no one gave a rat’s behind for their needs. No one suggested forgiving the loan they took out to start a small business, arguably a more socially useful act and a bigger risk than the bigger loans millions of students took for a very enjoyable four years.
The people at my local place problematicize my assumptions, as an academic might put it, in a way the people in my other worlds don’t. Everyone needs his views problematicized — and by people ideologically, culturally and economically different.
That means not only going to the places where we meet them, but being part of those places, part of them over time and with a commitment, so that we meet them as equals and as friends, who trust us enough to talk freely. That happens in dive bars and not many other places.
A song in another language
I was at our local place one night when karaoke started. A woman sang a lovely song in a language I didn’t recognize. It was one of those lilting songs that suddenly become dramatic at the end of the verse and then go back to lilting. The singer was a young Afghan woman who hangs out there with her boyfriend.
She can’t go home, but she can sing her home’s songs to people in a townie dive bar in a Pittsburgh suburb on the Beaver County line. Someday we’ll be talking and I’ll find out her story. Because we’re both there, both regulars, people sharing a living room.
The dive bar’s one of the few places left very different people can fall into conversation and talk across their differences. America needs a lot more dive bars.
David Mills’ previous column was “Three things I like about Pittsburgh.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.