Our eldest daughter’s friend’s family was moving away. They’d moved into the neighborhood a couple years before, buying a house that needed a lot of work, and they were going to take a bath on the sale. They’d had to tear up their lawn to put in a 50-foot sewer pipe, among other repairs.

The father told me they wanted to be closer to their families, especially as their parents were getting older, and they wanted the kids to see their grandparents a lot more. His wife wanted to move back home. She felt out of place in our little borough. The way he talked, I assumed they were moving to California or some other changing-their-lives-entirely place very far away, far away enough to justify losing a lot of money they didn’t have.

“Where are you going?” I asked.

“Crafton,” he said. Crafton was a 20-minute drive. We went to church in Crafton. We drove farther than that to go to the Carnegie (and its dinosaurs) or to a restaurant we liked or the old Borders book store on McKnight. My neighbor drove farther than that every day to go to work.

Advertise with us

Pittsburgh and Pittsburghers

We had moved here from Boston just a few years before, and I had never imagined such a thing. It was a revelation that Pittsburgh was a different place.

When I say I like Pittsburgh, I first mean I like Pittsburghers. (As a whole and with exceptions.) By “Pittsburgher,” I mean those established here with roots that go back at least to their parents and very often much further, and wide connections with friends and neighbors, and even with their friends and neighbors’ relatives.

The city and region do appeal. The price of living, for example, and the ease of getting around (if you have a car), and the state parks and the city’s cultural institutions, and how beautiful or at least interesting so much of the area is, etc. But the aspect that has made me a kind of Pittsburgh patriot is the people I know.

When I’ve mentioned the Pittsburghers’ virtues to people in other places, they will say, sometimes peevishly, suggesting some jealousy, that people are the same everywhere. I don’t think that’s true. New Yorkers are notoriously New Yorkers. There is a classic New England personality (which I will be happy to demonstrate).

And Pittsburghers are Pittsburghers. Why they, by which I mean you, are so is a matter of a long and complicated history, unique or nearly unique among American cities. It may be no moral credit to you, but still, it’s a thing.

Advertise with us

Care for connection

Here are three reasons I like Pittsburghers, among several. I apologize if this sounds a little romantic, but I’m an immigrant and we’re allowed to be romantic about a place that’s now both home and still a new land. Life is more interesting when things that were once new to you still feel new.

First, I like that Pittsburghers have such loyalty and care for their connections with family and friends and long-time acquaintances, as well to their places — and that the two, person and place, are so often combined. It’s great to be so grounded and to care so much for things you can literally put your finger on.

This doesn’t mean Pittsburghers treat me and my immigrant peers like outsiders. They treat us like natives.

It’s that when I’m with them, like at our townie bar, I realize they live in a world of human connections I can never enter. One evening, two women at opposite ends of the bar yelled back and forth about playing Barbies together and the boy they both had a crush on — 40 years ago. That kind of thing happens all the time.

Second, I like that Pittsburghers are always Pittsburghers. When asked where you’re from, a New Englander will tell you where he grew up, and Pittsburghers (and some Southerners) do this as well. Once in a while the specific borough, not generic “Pittsburgh.” Other Americans will tell you where they’re living now.

Advertise with us

I’ve met people embarrassed to admit their origins, some who went so far as to scrub their accents of any trace of home. I’ve only met a few Pittsburghers like that, and they were usually trying to make themselves something else, like a New Yorker. And at least that’s an aspiration, not exactly a rejection.

Care for Pittsburgh

Third, I like that Pittsburghers want you to like their city and region. People in many other places so often seem too indifferent to their home to care that you like it. Or else they don’t see their region as a thing to identify with and care about. It’s just the place they live. The result, I assume, of a transient society.

Not here. Our first few years here, people keep asking, sometimes a little anxiously, what we thought of Pittsburgh. They eagerly described the area’s high points and virtues. They were pleased when we said we’d been there or done that. I had come from a place where we would rarely ask that. We’d ask, “Why are you here and why are you talking to someone you don’t know?”

They loved explaining the unique things, like french fries on sandwiches and salads, and Friday pierogie sales, and words like “nebby,” and the belt system of roads, and Sophie Masloff. They loved telling us the history, including the sad things, like the collapse of the steel industry, and the happy things, like the Steelers’ six Super Bowl victories.

That said, it did sometimes feel like the city should have a billboard off the Turnpike exit saying “Welcome to Pittsburgh. Please like us. Please? Pretty Please? We’re not as bad as you think.” Most cities, at least big eastern cities, could have a billboard saying, “You’re lucky we let you in.”

Advertise with us

Pittsburgh would have benefited from thinking like that. But it’s not a Pittsburgher thing to do. Which is a virtue.

David Mills’ previous column was “Josh Shapiro and Corey O’Connor promise to get the work done, but will they?”.