Prostitutes deserve respect. Two weeks ago, we editorialized in support of Councilwoman Barb Warwick’s change to city law to make prostitution a summary offense rather than a misdemeanor. The ordinance briefly highlighted people not often thought about, and not always respected as human beings who live very hard lives and do the best they can.
I think of some conversations I’ve heard where nice people talked with contempt of “whores” or spoke as if they go on the street the way the speakers go out to dinner. We could do better. How we treat them is a kind of test. They aren’t, in fact, the real prostitutes.
Journalistic cruelty
A few years ago, a Connecticut newspaper ran a story titled “City police charge 15 with prostitution,” with a box giving their names and ages and below it their mug shots. The newspaper was rebuked by someone many would not expect, the leader of the state’s social conservatives, Peter Wolfgang.
It was a cruel thing to do and I’d like to know what the editors thought they were doing. It failed the basic and easy to apply moral standard, either in Jesus’s form, “Do unto others as you would have them do unto you” or in Rabbi Hillel’s, “Whatever is hateful and distasteful to you, do not do to your fellow man.”
In the editors’ case, only publish about others what you (at your best and most honest, that is) would want them to publish about you. And also, don’t punch down.
Publicly shaming the women never works, Peter said. “And why would it? Look at those poor women. Look at their sadness. Look at their bruises! What those photos elicit in me is pity, not whatever sort of moral outrage the paper is expecting from the public.”
A few years before that, he’d worked with a human rights activist for a state law against human trafficking. He remembered a former prostitute explaining at their press conference that it was married men from the big insurance companies and industry head offices “who would pay the hourly rate at the hotels at the Berlin Turnpike to be with her. ‘They all loved their families,’ she said contemptuously.”
Those guys were the ones who should have mug shots in the newspaper, he continued. “You have to catch those married men who supposedly love their families and put THEIR faces in the newspaper. Then watch the market for prostitution dry up overnight once the community knows who and what they are. But shaming these poor women accomplishes absolutely zip. It just adds to their misery.”
Whether Peter’s suggestion meets the moral standard is a question, because none of us would want it done to us. But at least it points out that if a city is not going to expose married men that way, it should definitely not expose vulnerable working women that way.
The problem with shaming
And that’s the problem with public shaming of this sort, the kind that wants to change people by holding them up for public abuse. It’s so often directed against the most vulnerable, the people easiest to denigrate without risking reprisal, the people who have the fewest defenders because they can’t give anyone anything and they can’t threaten to get revenge on anyone.
From time to time, someone tries to popularize the idea of shaming people into doing better, when people rediscover the coercive power of public opinion. Conservatives apply the idea to people of whose sexual lives they disapprove. (People on the left have their own set of subjects for shaming. It’s too easy and too much fun. Few can resist.)
I remember a bit of a social media buzz a few years ago to “Make sex work shameful again.” One of our writers, Mary Pezzulo, objected, explaining, “They are quite accustomed to being shamed, and it’s sunken in. Sometimes trafficked women show up at the Friendship Room for a bowl of soup and say ‘I can’t believe you’d let someone like me eat with you!’ They already know what you think. They think that, and worse things, about themselves.”
She described the ways people wind up there. They can be kidnapped or sold by their parents or wind up on the street “because of mental illness or just plain bad luck, and they ended up in the hands of pimps. The pimps get them hooked on heroin. Try escaping from anywhere when you’re struggling with a heroin addiction.”
Things will only get worse. “If they go to the police for help, the police will promptly arrest them for prostitution, which is a felony. And when you’re a heroin addict who was picked up for prostitution, you go to prison.”
Selective shaming
The advocate of shame as a way to change people would never post, “Make exploiting workers shameful” or “Make polluting the rivers shameful.” He might know those people. He might be one of them, or he might want something from them.
He directs his charges at prostitutes, not their customers. He doesn’t say, “Make buying sex shameful again,” which would have more chance of succeeding, but might hit men he knows.
The truly shameful actions don’t get shamed. The truly shameful actors, who have a choice whether or not to sell themselves, don’t get shamed.
If you want to point to people guilty of selling themselves, you’ll want to look at the state house and the capitol building, the tall buildings downtown, the big universities, to any place where power can be gained by abandoning a principle. Or look in the mirror, because few of us have never denied what we believe to get something we wanted.
If you must call someone a whore, remember that he might very well be voting on the floor of the Senate or wear an expensive suit while doing billion dollar deals or have a list of degrees after his name. But treat with respect people who are doing the best they can.
David Mills’s previous column was “Frederick Douglass would condemn modern Christians for siding with the oppressors.” Mary Pezzulo’s article was “If You Shame A Sex Worker…”.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.