People started chanting “Sell the team” in the sixth inning of the Pirates home opener, with the Yankees ahead 7 to 1. They didn’t chant again, surprisingly, I’m guessing because, just 1/243rd of the way through the season, they had already fallen into ‘despair.

My friend, a Bronx-born Yankees fan, was enjoying the carnage, though feeling bad for the Pirates. I, who grew up in Massachusetts and am a Red Sox fan, was cheering for the Pirates, though with the same feeling you have when re-watching “Old Yeller” knowing that the dog is going to die.

The Yankees, as is well-known, have infernal help, but the Pirates still looked bad, and they haven’t given us any hope since that they will get better.

What about Nutting?

I asked people at my local place and others what they think the team’s billionaire owner Bob Nutting should do with the team and why he should do it. Someone in southwestern Pa. must approve of the way he runs the team, but I couldn’t find him.

Advertise with us

“He sold Seven Springs. He should have sold the Pirates instead,” said Bob, a businessman.

“We don’t need to be the farm team for the rest of the league,” said Linda, a bar owner. “We bring up players, we develop them, and then we lose them, for no money or anything.” Nutting has to make a profit, she said, running a business herself, “but he could put a little bit into the team.” That “little bit” was said in a sarcastic voice.

Mark, a lawyer of Irish heritage, pointed to the parallel example of the Glazer family, who own both the Tampa Bay Buccaneers and the English soccer team Manchester United. It’s a little depressing to think that Nutting is not alone.

The Glazers almost destroyed United “through financialization,” Mark said. “It will take years for United, formerly the richest club in the world, to recover. And yet. They have profited. United still makes money for them. It’s only the team, the stadium, the employees, and the supporters who suffer.”

“He sucks as the Pirates owner,” declared Mike, a machinist. A knowledgeable baseball fan — apparently more knowledgeable than Nutting — he listed the owner’s failings, and it was a long list, which can be summarized as trying to squeeze as much money as he can out of the team because he doesn’t care how well the team does on the field.

Advertise with us

Other small market teams knew how to win, he added, particularly by keeping their core intact and adding young players. Even when the Pirates were good, the team “didn’t take that final step,” by spending money on the star or stars it needed.

“If we weren’t a baseball town, the team would have left years ago,” he continued. The fans’ loyalty and the fact that we keep paying to watch the team keeps it here. “That’s the frustrating thing. We’re the Cleveland Browns of baseball.”

Bob Nutting is not a baseball fan, said Ray, a playwright. “He’s a businessman. That’s why he should sell the team.”

Everyone said sell

Everyone I talked to thought that Nutting should sell the team. Mine wasn’t a scientific sample of southwestern Pennsylvanians, but I’m guessing the results were within a margin of error of 0%.

I asked them why Nutting should sell the team. It’s a business and he owns it, after all. Most of us would resent being told what to do with something we owned, especially if it meant losing money we could make.

Advertise with us

“The purpose of owning a business is to produce a product people want,” Mike said. “If you own a baseball team, you’re supposed to entertain your fan base. How do you entertain a fan base? Win!”

Mark argued that owners are stewards of enterprises like baseball teams, with responsibility for the common good and not just their bottom line.

Dave, a pastor, put the point in a more philosophical way. “Businesses enter into a kind of civic covenant,” he explained in an email. They can certainly make a profit, “but they are obliged to support the good of the community in which they are embedded and from whose order they are able to profit.”

Some businesses, he continued, “acquire more specific obligations.” Sports teams benefit from being part of a league that has an effective monopoly the law protects. That obliges them “to behave according to the ethos of the league,” which is, as Mike put it, to win.

He’s making a lot of money, Ray said, so why would he sell the team? “Because you don’t forget where you come from, which is the worst mistake you can make. In business, or in life. That’s who you are. And it has slipped Bob Nutting’s mind.” He mentioned covering up Roberto Clemente’s memorial with an ad.

Advertise with us

Everyone I talked to had the sense that, as I wrote last year, there are rules for public life that override the mere legal rules of ownership. That includes the conviction that owners of baseball teams should care enough about their cities to field the best team they can afford.

An alternative

At the end of the “Sell the team” chant, one lone voice yelled out “Let’s go, Wild Things,” referring to Washington’s Frontier League team, whose home season starts on May 13th and who offer a much better game for the money than the Pirates, and who seem to be owned by people who like good baseball and want their team to do well.

We’re a baseball town, and fortunately we have an alternative to Mr. Nutting’s Pirates. But he should still sell the team to someone who cares.

David Mills is the deputy editorial page editor and a columnist for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: dmills@post-gazette.com. He wrote about the Wild Things in “Great baseball you probably don’t know about.”