JD Vance has a serious problem, and I have no confidence he will answer it well, because he hasn’t answered it well. He has bound himself to unpopular beliefs that could sabotage his political ambitions.

It’s a basic problem in politics, or would be if many politicians thought clearly about their own principles: How does a politician who fundamentally disagrees with the political consensus of the day operate, when so many choices will be compromises — and compromising?

What does he do when he believes an action profoundly wrong and his participation in government means at least indirect support of it? And when he might lose an election because he believes what he does?

The Catholic Vance

JD Vance is, famously or notoriously, depending on your point of view, a Catholic convert. He began life with his family’s anti-institutional Protestant Christianity, then became an atheist — he even had a brief period as a disciple of that moral disaster Ayn Rand — and later made his way to Catholicism, a movement he described in 2020 in a reflective essay in a Catholic magazine called The Lamp — titled, significantly, “How I joined the resistance.” He chose to become a Catholic because, as he had to swear when he joined, he believes everything the Catholic church teaches.

Advertise with us

The Catholic church, being very old and very big, has worked out its teaching in great and specific detail. Not just the broad “Thou shalt not kill,” for example, but a detailed idea of what “kill” means and to whom it applies. Put broadly, “kill” means “murder” and not all killing is murder.

For example — and this is the source of Vance’s problem — the “Catechism of the Catholic Church” declares: “From the first moment of his existence, a human being must be recognized as having the rights of a person — among which is the inviolable right of every innocent being to life.” No abortions, surgical or chemical.

Making the matter even more pointed, especially for a politician, the church teaches that this isn’t a matter just of revelation, of the inside divine knowledge the church claims to have. It teaches that this is a matter of the natural or moral law, as one of the truths everyone whatever their beliefs knows.

Vance used to believe that. When he ran for the Senate in 2022, his website included a section headed “Ban Abortion.” But that was before Donald Trump dangled before him the possibility of being vice president.

Trump, worried about the effect of a strong position against abortion would have on his reelection, after eight years of pretending to be pro-life, decided to essentially scrub the issue from the Republican party platform. Someone as politically attuned as Vance would have known what Trump really thought — and wanted.

Advertise with us

Vance goes further

Vance, for reasons unknown, and before Trump had announced his choice, decided to take this reversal even farther. Speaking on “Meet the Press” on July 7th, pressed on his views of abortion pills, he said, “Look, the Supreme Court made a decision that the American people should have access to that medication. Donald Trump has supported that opinion. I support that opinion.”

A little later in the interview, the host, Kristen Welker, asked him specifically about the abortion drug mifepristone. “But just to be clear: You support mifepristone being accessible?” Vance said, “Yes, Kristen, I do.”

You will have noticed the unbridgeable gap between what his church teaches and what he says on national television as (at that point) a possible vice presidential candidate, and one with obvious ambitions to become president himself some day. That may explain why he went farther: to sweeten the deal for Trump. It may have been a way of saying, “I won’t be Mike Pence.”

Vance’s Catholicism puts him at a disadvantage, compared to whoever turns out to be his opposite number. It’s politically easier to hold the conventional pieties of modern progressive liberalism, as Kamala Harris does. They’re more ideals than doctrines, binding in general but not always binding in particular.

They leave the politician a lot more wiggle room than do the doctrines of the Catholic Church. Except, significantly, on a few issues including abortion, where the liberal doctrine is as fixed and binding as the Catholic one. Most of America sits between the two orthodoxies, but — as Trump saw — closer to the Democratic one.

Advertise with us

The sad thing

The sad thing, if you don’t like seeing a man abandon his principles, is that Vance didn’t have to abandon them. In a major statement in 1995 titled “Evangelium Vitae,” Pope John Paul II said that an elected official could support legislation that the official believed was on balance pro-life, as long as his “absolute personal opposition to procured abortion was well known.”

JD Vance could have told Kristen Welker that he disagreed with the Supreme Court, but that he would not be wasting his limited political resources in fruitless opposition to the decision. He could then have said what he mostly said on “Meet the Press,” that he wanted to work to make having children easier and discourage abortion.

That would have been a good Catholic answer. But he didn’t give it.

David Mills is the deputy editorial page editor and a columnist for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: dmills@post-gazette.com. His previous column was “An attempted assassination, democracy, and the risk of civil war.”

This was later revised to add the title of JD Vance’s essay.