“No!” she said, laughing. “Yes!” I said. “No!” she said again, clearly pleased with herself. My granddaughter, about 2 1/​2, was telling me I couldn’t wave at her as I left the house.

She is at the age at which children say “no” to almost everything you suggest. They often say “no” as if saying “no” is funny. I think it’s the age at which children really start discovering themselves as individuals who can decide what to do, and what to think. Nothing says “Me” the way “No” does.

Some people complain about how childish our politicians can be, one in particular, but our nation would be better off if more people had maintained more of their inner 2-year-old.

The tight consensus

“You must believe and do this!” people in power say, whether they’re politicians, pundits, academics, influencers and anyone else with cultural status and authority, who therefore speak from a fairly narrow and fairly sharply defined range of views, because societies depend on people agreeing as much as possible and favor those who agree with the mainstream view.

Advertise with us

It’s in the air. It’s the view of things you get from the New York Times and The American Conservative, from TV news and TV stories, and certainly from every Republican and Democratic convention. And that’s the problem.

We conform too easily and the beliefs and practices to which we conform are too narrow and too limited and sometimes morally or otherwise wrong. Abolitionists before the Civil War saw the wickedness of slavery but many held racist views of the enslaved, because basically every white person at the time did.

That was what we might call the liberal or enlightened consensus of the time. And holy cow, some of them were deeply racist, to the point you wonder why they opposed slavery.

The more practically important the matter, the narrower the range of belief. Everyone loves diversity but only within limits. The more food choices, the better. The more ideological choices, the worse.

You may have, without anyone blinking, almost any spirituality you want, because no one thinks it does anything. Talk to God, talk to trees, talk to yourself, who cares. You may have, but not without protest and in some cases punishment, any economic view you want. Argue for nationalizing industry, stripping the state to the bone, people care about that.

Advertise with us

Outside the consensus

Step outside the consensus and look at it from either side and you will see how tight it is. You will find most people agreeing in an “It’s obvious” way, and you will find intelligent, thoughtful people who don’t agree at all. I’m not saying that the alternatives are right, but only that the “It’s obvious” consensus is almost never obvious.

Ask real socialists, like the people at the magazine Jacobin, about liberalism and they will point out how deeply American liberals are committed to capitalism. The liberals may fight with the right over the welfare policy and environmental regulation, but they agree with their opponents 100% on it being the obvious economic system, and on socialism just being wrong. One could cynically say they agree on the system that made them rich.

Libertarians would say the same thing from the opposite direction. They will point out how much the right and the liberals agree on the big role of the state, the faith libertarians call “statism.” The right may fight with the liberals over tax rates and (again) regulation, but they agree with their opponents on the need for a big state, and on libertarianism just being wrong. One could cynically say that they agree on the system and are just fighting over the spoils.

Jacobin may be the most anti-liberal magazine in the country and libertarians have as low or lower a view of mainstream Republicans as any Democrat. One favors corporate action, the other individualism, but both agree that the big thing, the consensus, makes major mistakes about the way the world is and the way it should be.

And both have thinkers of weight, the kind of people you have to take seriously. Two from the last century, for example, who were friends or at least friendly opponents, and well worth reading now.

Advertise with us

On the socialist side, Karl Polanyi, author of an important book called “The Great Transformation: The Political and Economic Origins of Our Time.” On the libertarian side, Friedrich Hayek, a Nobel Prize winner in economics and author of the classic “The Road to Serfdom” and “The Constitution of Liberty.”

Say “No” more

If you read them seriously, I think you will see that the mainstream story, the shared consensus, is not the only plausible way to understand economics, that the two alternatives arguably make as good or better a case. You have a wider range of ideas to consider.

But you have to say “No” to the consensus to see that.

We should say “No” as a general way of looking at popular ideas, treating them as guilty until proven innocent. We are better off, and better citizens, if we share the 2-year-old’s instinct to deny, tempered and guided by the adult desire to judge rightly and fairly. My granddaughter’s on to something.

David Mills is the deputy editorial page editor and a columnist for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: dmills@post-gazette.com. His previous column was “Thomas Jefferson knew what being a true American means. Trump doesn’t.”