My friend Digby took his place ev­ery Sun­day with the other Quak­ers among the peo­ple ring­ing the town com­mon pro­test­ing the Vi­et­nam War. For a while, they stood out even in the lib­eral-left col­lege town in which I grew up.

Most peo­ple be­lieved in the con­fi­dent lib­er­al­ism of the 50s and 60s, the be­lief in Amer­ica’s spe­cial des­tiny and in the best and bright­est who knew how to make the world work. Even­tu­ally, most got over that fan­tasy — it was a self-flat­ter­ing one — and start­ed op­pos­ing the war.

Rea­sons dif­fered, of course, from the es­tab­lish­ment idea that Amer­ica had un­wisely but in­no­cently got­ten in­volved in a war it couldn’t win to the rad­i­cal be­lief that Amer­ica’s im­pe­rial acts hurt weaker na­tions for self­ish and im­moral ends.

I was in ju­nior high then, and on the rad­i­cal end. All the po­lit­i­cal kids were, but (a les­son) al­most no one else. When I turned 18, I got a card from the gov­ern­ment tell­ing me to reg­is­ter for the draft, with threat­en­ing lan­guage, and I re­fused.

Advertise with us

In a prison camp

At the same time, in Vi­et­nam it­self, Marine 2nd Lieu­tenant James Warner was suf­fer­ing in a North Vi­et­nam­ese prison camp, the one in which John McCain was also im­pris­oned. He’d been shot down as the nav­i­ga­tor of an F4 Phan­tom just three miles into North Vi­et­nam.

“Most of us were tor­tured, and some of my com­rades died,” he wrote in the Wash­ing­ton Post in 1989. “I was tor­tured for most of the sum­mer of 1969. I de­vel­oped beri­beri from mal­nu­tri­tion. I had long bouts of dys­en­tery. I was in­fested with in­tes­ti­nal par­a­sites. I spent 13 months in sol­i­tary con­fine­ment.” He stayed there, con­tin­u­ally abused, for 1979 days. He was, from all re­ports, a leader and pro­tec­tor of the other men there.

Some years ago, late at night, I stood in the Warners’ kitchen talk­ing to Jim. His wife and I had be­come email friends and she’d in­vited my fam­ily to stay with them when we were in the area. He was still vis­i­bly in pain from the tor­ture he’d gone through 40 years be­fore. We talked about pol­i­tics, kids, dogs, the cost of keep­ing up a house, that kind of thing. He had strong be­liefs, but held them genially.

As I went back up­stairs, I re­al­ized I’d spent fif­teen min­utes shoot­ing the breeze with a hero. Not just for his cour­age and the way he gave him­self for oth­ers in Vi­et­nam, which was more than enough by it­self, but for the way he now thought about what he had done.

Loving the flag

He and oth­ers were re­leased in March 1973 and flown to a base in the Phil­ip­pines. “As I stepped out of the air­craft I looked up and saw the flag,” he wrote in his Post story. “I caught my breath, then, as tears filled my eyes, I sa­luted it. I never loved my coun­try more than at that mo­ment.”

Advertise with us

It hurt him to see other Amer­i­cans mis­treat­ing the flag, an act of con­tempt for the coun­try for which he’d just spent 5 1/2 years in a Com­mu­nist prison camp. But that was the Amer­ica he loved. An in­ter­ro­ga­tor had shown him a photo of Amer­i­cans burn­ing the flag to pro­test the war. “There,” he said. “People in your coun­try pro­test against your cause. That proves that you are wrong.”

Jim said no, it didn’t. “That proves that I am right. In my coun­try we are not afraid of free­dom, even if it means that peo­ple dis­agree with us.” The of­fi­cer “was on his feet in an in­stant, his face pur­ple with rage. He smashed his fist onto the ta­ble and screamed at me to shut up. While he was rant­ing I was as­ton­ished to see pain, com­pounded by fear, in his eyes.”

He went through all he had and still thought it worth­while to pro­tect the free­dom of peo­ple who de­spised him and his peers. I’m not sure I could man­age that. But he­roes can.

A good man

Given our up­bring­ings, I don’t think Jim and I could have helped be­ing the young men we were and mak­ing the choices we did. He couldn’t help be­ing the ide­al­is­tic, pa­tri­otic young man who en­listed in the mil­i­tary and then took a post that would get him sent to Vi­et­nam to fight the Com­mu­nists who wanted to take away other peo­ple’s free­dom. But he chose to be­come the man he is.

Jim’s a hero, a good man to be em­u­lated. Yet if I de­scribed his po­lit­i­cal views, some read­ers would hate him. That would be a judg­ment on them. He­roes may be very wrong — Jim and I would dis­agree a lot on a lot — but their char­ac­ter earns them def­er­ence, es­pe­cially from peo­ple who are, how to say this? not he­roes, but peo­ple who mea­sure their char­ac­ter by their bumper stick­ers, and whose hatefulness is poisoning our political culture.

Advertise with us

David Mills is the deputy editorial page editor and a columnist for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: dmills@post-gazette.com. His previous column was “A word in favor of Pittsburghers who like Trump.” He described another aspect of his political upbringing in “Democracy is under assault by people who don’t believe in it.”