On Wed­nes­day, mil­lions of Amer­i­cans, but not Don­ald Trump, will hear some­one tell them some­thing dis­turb­ing about them­selves they need to hear, and say it lit­er­ally to their face.

On Ash Wed­nes­day, the first day of Lent, pen­i­tents walk to the front of the church to have a priest rub a cross on their fore­head with ashes and hear him say, “Re­mem­ber that you are dust and to dust you will re­turn.”

Mr. Trump would be a bet­ter man, and there­fore our na­tion would be bet­ter off, if he heard the words and be­lieved them.

A dark thought

“You are dust and to dust you will re­turn” is a dark thought and it’s meant to be. It sum­ma­rizes the ba­sic Chris­tian story of why man is who he is: That God cre­ated man, that man will­fully broke their friend­ship, that be­cause he broke their friend­ship bad things hap­pen to him and to the world (and he him­self does many of those bad things), and that even­tu­ally ev­ery­thing dies.

Advertise with us

It rec­og­nizes what ev­ery­one should see, that the world we live in does not look like the world a good and lov­ing God would have cre­ated. Some­thing went badly wrong.

If you be­lieve in God, that’s a prob­lem. If you don’t be­lieve in God, it’s not a prob­lem but it’s still a fact. The world’s screwed up, and we’re part of the prob­lem, and we should try not to be.

Most of us know this be­cause we know our­selves. I’d like to think I’m a good enough guy, as guys go, but I know with toe-curl­ing shame how bad I can be. I have a fairly good idea how un­sat­is­fac­tory fam­ily and friends can be.

The re­li­gions dif­fer a lot in how they un­der­stand the state of man and what has been done or can be done about it. But they all say in their own ways that we are not sat­is­fac­tory, that we’re at least a lit­tle off and maybe quite bent and twisted, that we are not who should be. They as­sume, speak­ing broadly, that we can­not get bet­ter with­out know­ing and ad­mit­ting how de­fi­cient if not of­fen­sively bad we are.

He has no idea

I wrote a few weeks ago against the in­sane idea that Don­ald Trump is in any mean­ing­ful sense a Chris­tian. Which of course does not pre­vent him from be­ing pres­i­dent or from be­ing a good pres­i­dent. But he can­not be a good man and there­for he can­not be a good pres­i­dent, with­out be­liev­ing the truth about him­self that the Ash Wed­nes­day rit­ual de­clares. It wouldn’t mat­ter if he knew it in Jew­ish or Muslim or Hindu or other terms, as long as he knew it.

Advertise with us

We have no ev­i­dence that Mr. Trump does. He does not seem to have any idea that he is an un­sat­is­fac­tory hu­man be­ing, at best, that he may even be bent and twisted. That’s es­pe­cially bad for a per­son be­cause part of be­ing bent and twisted is that you don’t know it. You think you’re straight as an ar­row.

Which means you keep do­ing bent and twisted things, which only bends and twists you more, and you be­lieve that the peo­ple who re­ally are straight as an ar­row are the bent and twisted ones. The ev­i­dence is that they op­pose you. This ex­plains a lot about Trump on the cam­paign trail and in of­fice.

The Don­ald Trump who lies like the rest of us breathe, who be­trays friends and al­lies, who cheats or tries to cheat when­ever he wants some­thing he didn’t get (like a ma­jor­ity of the elec­toral col­lege), who speaks of the poor and vul­ner­a­ble with con­tempt (re­mem­ber his dis­mis­sive re­mark about “sh*thole coun­tries”), who didn’t see any­thing wrong with brag­ging about grop­ing women not his wife, who ... I don’t need to go on: He does not act like some­one who knows he is dust and to dust he will re­turn, and he must try to be a good man.

He needs to be better

If only he did. We need him to say, sin­cerely, “I am not who I should be. I need to be bet­ter,” because that is the only way anyone can change for the better. It’s the only way we unbend and untwist.

If you re­ject ev­ery­thing he be­lieves, you should want this to mit­i­gate the ef­fects of his be­liefs. If you agree with him, you should want this even more than any­one else, be­cause you want him to suc­ceed and he would do much better did he not act the way he does, and he would not act the way he does if he did not believe in his own perfection.

Advertise with us

Please remember, Donald Trump, that you like all the rest of us, are dust, and to dust you will return.

David Mills is the as­so­ci­ate ed­i­to­rial page ed­i­tor and col­um­nist for the Pitts­burgh Post-Ga­zette: dmi­lls@post-ga­zette.com. His previous column was “Decent people tip, and well. Bad people don’t.”