The story pops up now and again on so­cial me­dia as a sub­ject for the ten-minute-hate, and a jus­ti­fi­able one too. Some­one stiffs a waiter or a bar­tender and tries to ex­cuse them­selves for do­ing it.

Some­one signs the credit card re­ceipt at the restau­rant and puts a zero in the space for a tip, writ­ing in “I give my money to char­ity” or “I save my money for Je­sus” (those of you with Bibles, see Mat­thew 25:31-46). Or they give a sup­pos­edly prin­ci­pled rea­son, like “I don’t be­lieve in tip­ping” or “Your boss should pay you bet­ter” or “Tip­ping lets busi­nesses ex­ploit their work­ers.”

Or worse, the very worst, the low­est of the low, they scrawl some sneer like “Get a bet­ter job.”

The deal you agree to

You see the same lines, es­pe­cially the last two, in Red­dit and so­cial me­dia dis­cus­sions. A New Yorker ar­ti­cle pub­lished at the end of Decem­ber got peo­ple in those cir­cles talk­ing, mak­ing the same ar­gu­ments in that self-re­gard­ing New Yorker way.

Advertise with us

I thought of it when I had to tell a friend com­plain­ing about tip­ping that he was punch­ing down on peo­ple just try­ing to get by. He was abashed. He had not meant to, but let his ar­gu­ment carry him away.

If you go to a busi­ness whose em­ploy­ees live by their tips, you tip. That’s the deal you agree to when you walk through the door. It’s a kind of so­cial com­pact as well as a so­cial con­ven­tion, the kind of gen­eral agree­ment through which so­ci­et­ies func­tion. It’s the way civil so­ci­ety works in pro­vid­ing some ser­vices, like hot meals at your ta­ble and drinks at the bar.

Yes, these con­ven­tions gen­er­ally fa­vor the owner over the worker. But you don’t help cre­ate a new, bet­ter world by hurt­ing the vul­ner­a­ble. You’re not hurt­ing “The Man” when you stiff the waiter. You’re hurt­ing the waiter. You’re hurt­ing some­one like you, but for a few ac­ci­dents of his­tory and the difference of a few num­bers in your bank ac­counts.

You have the choice of spend­ing a few ex­tra dol­lars, which you should have fac­tored into your plans be­fore you walked in, or of hurt­ing some­one who needs those ex­tra dol­lars. Ba­si­cally, you can pay some­one for serv­ing you or you can pay your­self to hurt them for serv­ing you.

Mak­ing a dif­fer­ence

You tip be­cause it makes a dif­fer­ence in peo­ple’s lives. People you have seen and talked to. That’s what de­cent peo­ple do. If you leave with­out tip­ping, think­ing you have a high-minded rea­son, you’re ly­ing to your­self and do­ing oth­ers an in­justice. If your an­swer is “Get a bet­ter job,” you’re a pig.

Advertise with us

You may not like tip­ping, you may not want to tip, you may not be­lieve in it, you may think it’s an un­just sys­tem, but you tip. If you don’t want to tip peo­ple who de­pend on tips, stay home.

The lines people use to excuse not tipping rationalize our own interests. We, the kind of peo­ple who write for and read newspapers like this one, need to be alert to how much class dif­fer­ences af­fect the way we see the world and how those of us with ad­van­tages can fail to see how the world looks to those who don’t have such ad­van­tages.

We have to work at seeing what tips mean to the people who get them, for example. I’ve thought about tipping partly because one of our daugh­ters worked in a drive-through Star­bucks in a very af­flu­ent com­mu­nity nearby. Hers was a hard job, be­tween poor work con­di­tions — it was Star­bucks — and some hor­ri­ble cus­tom­ers, and the tips were the one thing that made it work­able.

The system must change. Work for that. Work to raise the minimum wage, especially for waiters and their peers, for whom it’s barely $2 an hour. But until they’re better off, while they still need your money, tip.

A lit­tle and a lot

Open­ing the door to her huge stone man­sion, the kind you see in mov­ies or a hy­per-wealthy Pitts­burgh bor­ough, the woman took the bags of Chi­nese food she’d or­dered, and handed my son a quar­ter.

Advertise with us

He was work­ing to make money for col­lege. A quar­ter did not help.

Another eve­ning, he took a much smaller or­der to an apart­ment “on the wrong side of the tracks,” as peo­ple used to say, to a Black fam­ily hav­ing, the father told him, a treat. He handed my son a lot of money for a tip — for some reason I re­mem­ber $8 — a quar­ter or more of the to­tal bill.

My son told me how bare the apart­ment was, and see­ing the mother and chil­dren sit­ting around the ta­ble smil­ing at him. He tried to turn down the money but the man in­sisted, tell­ing him he’d worked for it, and to say no again would have been dis­re­spect­ful.

That was a good man, a de­cent man, the kind of man who gives you hope for the world. How do you know? He tipped, gen­er­ously. He helped some­one vul­ner­a­ble, though not as vul­ner­a­ble as he was. Be that man.

David Mills is the as­so­ci­ate ed­i­to­rial page ed­i­tor and col­um­nist for the Pitts­burgh Post-Ga­zette: dmi­lls@post-ga­zette.com. His previous column was “Some Americans (but not you and me) can avoid paying for their mistakes.”