The story pops up now and again on social media as a subject for the ten-minute-hate, and a justifiable one too. Someone stiffs a waiter or a bartender and tries to excuse themselves for doing it.
Someone signs the credit card receipt at the restaurant and puts a zero in the space for a tip, writing in “I give my money to charity” or “I save my money for Jesus” (those of you with Bibles, see Matthew 25:31-46). Or they give a supposedly principled reason, like “I don’t believe in tipping” or “Your boss should pay you better” or “Tipping lets businesses exploit their workers.”
Or worse, the very worst, the lowest of the low, they scrawl some sneer like “Get a better job.”
The deal you agree to
You see the same lines, especially the last two, in Reddit and social media discussions. A New Yorker article published at the end of December got people in those circles talking, making the same arguments in that self-regarding New Yorker way.
I thought of it when I had to tell a friend complaining about tipping that he was punching down on people just trying to get by. He was abashed. He had not meant to, but let his argument carry him away.
If you go to a business whose employees live by their tips, you tip. That’s the deal you agree to when you walk through the door. It’s a kind of social compact as well as a social convention, the kind of general agreement through which societies function. It’s the way civil society works in providing some services, like hot meals at your table and drinks at the bar.
Yes, these conventions generally favor the owner over the worker. But you don’t help create a new, better world by hurting the vulnerable. You’re not hurting “The Man” when you stiff the waiter. You’re hurting the waiter. You’re hurting someone like you, but for a few accidents of history and the difference of a few numbers in your bank accounts.
You have the choice of spending a few extra dollars, which you should have factored into your plans before you walked in, or of hurting someone who needs those extra dollars. Basically, you can pay someone for serving you or you can pay yourself to hurt them for serving you.
Making a difference
You tip because it makes a difference in people’s lives. People you have seen and talked to. That’s what decent people do. If you leave without tipping, thinking you have a high-minded reason, you’re lying to yourself and doing others an injustice. If your answer is “Get a better job,” you’re a pig.
You may not like tipping, you may not want to tip, you may not believe in it, you may think it’s an unjust system, but you tip. If you don’t want to tip people who depend on tips, stay home.
The lines people use to excuse not tipping rationalize our own interests. We, the kind of people who write for and read newspapers like this one, need to be alert to how much class differences affect the way we see the world and how those of us with advantages can fail to see how the world looks to those who don’t have such advantages.
We have to work at seeing what tips mean to the people who get them, for example. I’ve thought about tipping partly because one of our daughters worked in a drive-through Starbucks in a very affluent community nearby. Hers was a hard job, between poor work conditions — it was Starbucks — and some horrible customers, and the tips were the one thing that made it workable.
The system must change. Work for that. Work to raise the minimum wage, especially for waiters and their peers, for whom it’s barely $2 an hour. But until they’re better off, while they still need your money, tip.
A little and a lot
Opening the door to her huge stone mansion, the kind you see in movies or a hyper-wealthy Pittsburgh borough, the woman took the bags of Chinese food she’d ordered, and handed my son a quarter.
He was working to make money for college. A quarter did not help.
Another evening, he took a much smaller order to an apartment “on the wrong side of the tracks,” as people used to say, to a Black family having, the father told him, a treat. He handed my son a lot of money for a tip — for some reason I remember $8 — a quarter or more of the total bill.
My son told me how bare the apartment was, and seeing the mother and children sitting around the table smiling at him. He tried to turn down the money but the man insisted, telling him he’d worked for it, and to say no again would have been disrespectful.
That was a good man, a decent man, the kind of man who gives you hope for the world. How do you know? He tipped, generously. He helped someone vulnerable, though not as vulnerable as he was. Be that man.
David Mills is the associate editorial page editor and columnist for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: dmills@post-gazette.com. His previous column was “Some Americans (but not you and me) can avoid paying for their mistakes.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.