More than half the na­tion’s Re­pub­li­cans see Don­ald Trump as a “per­son of faith,” mean­ing some kind of se­ri­ous Chris­tian, which strikes me, to be hon­est, as prepos­ter­ous. And worse than prepos­ter­ous: dan­ger­ous.

It ex­presses a huge er­ror in dis­cern­ment among a large and po­lit­i­cally pow­er­ful group, giv­ing them a def­i­nite an­swer to the per­il­ous ques­tion of who is on God’s side. Or, as it is asked in Amer­i­can pol­i­tics: Whose side is God on?

I think the an­swer is al­ways “ev­ery­one’s and no one’s.” What that means in any po­lit­i­cal sys­tem takes a lot of care­ful thought — and, the re­li­gious per­son would add, prayer and prac­tice. You have to do­ing the thing se­ri­ously to have any idea how to ap­ply it.

Whose side is God on? We are def­i­nitely not good enough nor wise enough to an­swer “Mine.” But that is what this sadly wide­spread be­lief in Trump’s Chris­ti­an­ity en­cour­ages, and that’s why it’s dan­ger­ous.

Advertise with us

The prepos­ter­ous Trump

In say­ing “prepos­ter­ous,” I’m not mak­ing any judg­ment about the sta­tus of Trump’s soul be­fore God. That’s a mys­tery to any hu­man ob­server, be­cause we have no idea at all why he is the way he is. I might not have done as well, and you might not have done as well, with what­ever con­di­tions warped a lit­tle boy grow­ing up in Queens into Don­ald Trump.

We can’t know why he is who he is, but we can know who he is by the ev­i­dence, and what­ever he is, he is not a man of faith. We must ap­ply what we find to eval­u­at­ing him as a pol­i­ti­cian, and his followers must apply it to how much trust they can place in him.

Trump shows no in­ter­est at all in Chris­ti­an­ity — his is some kind of Prot­es­tant ver­sion — ex­cept as a po­lit­i­cal aid. He’s happy to have a bunch of prom­i­nent preach­ers tell their fol­low­ers he’s a man of God. He’ll stand still in the Oval Of­fice with his head bowed while they pray for him, and (cru­cially) peo­ple get it on film. He’s happy to en­dorse a cou­ple is­sues re­li­gious peo­ple care about that fit with what he cares about.

I think, for what it’s worth, that he didn’t ap­point the three Supreme Court justices he did be­cause he thought they would vote against Roe v. Wade, but be­cause he thought they would vote on other is­sues as he wanted them to. How of­ten, if ever, has he spo­ken of the un­born as a pro-lifer nat­u­rally would? The nom­i­na­tions got him a two­fer, court de­ci­sions he wanted and happy vot­ers he wanted to please.

Advertise with us

No evidence

Trump shows no ev­i­dence that he cares about the prac­tice of the faith, that he ever prays, reads his Bible, does any­thing be­cause he thinks his re­li­gion re­quires it — that he even has a re­li­gion that might re­quire any­thing of him. You can find no ev­i­dence in all his talks since he first be­gan run­ning for pres­i­dent that Chris­ti­an­ity has formed his mind in any way.

He does not speak as a man who has any clue about in­trin­sic and uni­ver­sal hu­man dig­nity. About kind­ness and for­give­ness. About mercy.

You may re­mem­ber the stunt he pulled with the Bible dur­ing the George Floyd pro­tests, walk­ing from the White House to St. John’s church, just to stand in front of the church sign and hold up a Bible, after a couple minues in which he and his aides tried to figure out what to do with it. He then gave a short talk all about mak­ing Amer­ica great again with no re­li­gious con­tent what­so­ever. Then he walked back to the White House.

Who knows what he was do­ing, ex­cept blas­phe­mously us­ing the Bible as po­lit­i­cal prop. His evan­gel­i­cal sup­port­ers pride them­selves on be­ing “Bible Chris­tians,” and this both­ered them not at all.

Advertise with us

Far from be­ing “a man of faith,” Trump’s a text­book ex­am­ple of what some writ­ers call the “post-Chris­tian” or “post-re­li­gious” man. He’s un­re­li­gious in a way no se­ri­ous athe­ist can be, be­cause the athe­ist cares cares about the ul­ti­mate ques­tions. He’s in the same uni­verse of thought as the re­li­gious, only with a dif­fer­ent an­swer than theirs. As far as I can tell, Don­ald Trump doesn’t re­al­ize there are any ul­ti­mate ques­tions.

He is who he is

Hav­ing said all this, I don’t hold Don­ald Trump’s lack of ac­tual re­li­gion against him, as a per­son or pol­i­ti­cian. We don’t know why peo­ple be­lieve what they be­lieve. Chris­ti­an­ity teaches that be­lief is a gift that we don’t de­serve.

And it com­pli­cates the mat­ter by claim­ing that peo­ple can truly be­lieve with­out know­ing it. (Nar­nia read­ers will re­mem­ber Emeth in “The Last Bat­tle.”) The New Tes­ta­ment writ­ers rank love of oth­ers much higher than ex­plicit be­lief.

Don­ald Trump is who Don­ald Trump is. He’s not the devil. I re­spect peo­ple who vote for him be­cause they think he’s the best can­di­date or be­cause they have to, given the al­ter­na­tives. Elec­toral pol­i­tics is a messy thing.

Advertise with us

But for heaven’s sake, don’t claim that he’s a re­li­gious man. And don’t use that as a rea­son to feel God is on your side.

David Mills is the as­so­ci­ate ed­i­to­rial page ed­i­tor and col­um­nist for the Pitts­burgh Post-Ga­zette: dmi­lls@post-ga­zette.com. His previous column was “The babe in the manger, the pope's new blessings and our hope for the world.”