Depend­ing on how you un­der­stand the world, you may think the Christ­mas story plau­si­ble and true, plau­si­ble but un­true, im­plau­si­ble but who knows, im­plau­si­ble but untrue, or ri­dic­u­lous. But it seems to me nat­u­ral that we’d want it to be true as a state­ment about the deep­est truth of the world, even if not true as a state­ment about hu­man his­tory.

The story’s the story of a baby who wasn’t just a baby, but the an­swer to ev­ery­thing. The one who, as the last book in the Bible says, at the end of his­tory “shall wipe away all tears from their eyes; and there shall be no more death, nei­ther sor­row, nor cry­ing, nei­ther shall there be any more pain: for the for­mer things are passed away.”

The world sucks. For many peo­ple, it sucks 24/​7. We want to be­lieve that what­ever or who­ever runs the uni­verse saw our dis­tress and joined us, so that we could en­joy some hap­pi­ness in this world and com­plete hap­pi­ness in the next, that good bat­tles evil in the world now and will even­tu­ally win.

Pope Francis and the baby

Advertise with us

One way to un­der­stand Pope Francis is that he be­lieves the story to be true, as his­tory and as story. God’s in­car­na­tion as a hu­man was the per­fect act of love, which hu­man be­ings, in­clud­ing most Cath­o­lics, fail to im­i­tate very well. (I in­clude my­self in that.)

The pope tries to make the Christ­mas story’s prom­ise more ob­vi­ous and more prac­ti­cal in the Cath­o­lic church’s life. That in­cludes ex­tend­ing the vis­i­ble signs of God’s love to ev­ery­one, in­clud­ing — or es­pe­cially — those Cath­o­lics have tra­di­tion­ally pushed away. That baby came for ev­ery­one, even those who don’t know it.

The pope tries to do this in the state­ment “Fi­du­cia Sup­pli­cans,” is­sued a week ago and in nano­sec­onds the sub­ject of con­dem­na­tion from the Cath­o­lic right and praise from the Cath­o­lic and sec­u­lar left. Both got it wrong.

It didn’t help that the press, and es­pe­cially the ed­i­tors who write head­lines, al­most uni­ver­sally bun­gled the story. They wrote it as if the pope had ap­proved a ver­sion of same-sex mar­riage and had crossed a hith­erto un­cross­able line.

The state­ment it­self says in the third and fourth para­graphs that it does not change “in any way” the church’s teach­ing. It makes some ef­fort, in about 5,000 words, to make cru­cial dis­tinc­tions, in­clud­ing that be­tween of­fer­ing God’s bless­ing to peo­ple and ap­prov­ing of ev­ery­thing they do.

Advertise with us

Many re­port­ers and oth­ers seem to think that a bless­ing is a seal of ap­proval. It’s in fact a re­quest for God’s help. “One who asks for a bless­ing shows him­self to be in need of God’s sav­ing pres­ence in his life,” the state­ment ex­plains. The pope thinks peo­ple who aren’t liv­ing by all the church’s rules should still be given a bless­ing when they ask.

What’s Francis doing?

What is Francis do­ing in “Fi­du­cia Sup­pli­cans”? Two theo­lo­gians, both con­ser­va­tive as that’s usu­ally de­fined, as am I, see what the pope is do­ing.

Holly Tay­lor Cool­man, who teaches at Prov­i­dence Col­lege, de­scribed the heart of the state­ment as the claim that when peo­ple ask a priest for a bless­ing, he should not make “an ex­haus­tive moral anal­y­sis” the pre­con­di­tion for giv­ing it. They “should not be re­quired to have prior moral per­fec­tion.”

She ex­plains: “This is not only the or­di­nary prac­tice of priests in pas­to­ral min­is­try, but it is close to the heart of the gos­pel: ‘We love be­cause he first loved us.’ My only sug­ges­tion right now is that we lin­ger a bit in I John: ‘God is love, and who­ever re­mains in love re­mains in God and God in him.’”

Advertise with us

Robert Bar­ron says that “Fi­du­cia Sup­pli­cans is very much con­gru­ent with Pope Francis’s long-held con­vic­tion that those who do not live up to the full de­mand of the Church’s moral teach­ing are nev­er­the­less loved and cher­ished by God and in­vited to ac­cept the Lord’s of­fer of for­give­ness.”

Not be­ing a theo­lo­gian, I grant that the the­ol­ogy may be as prob­lem­atic as some theo­lo­gians say (theo­lo­gians who are not among the Francis-hat­ers). I don’t think it is, but even if prob­lem­atic, it of­fers an­other step along the tra­jec­tory set by that baby in the man­ger. If the church doesn’t offer this kind of blessing, Catholics must find other ways to show God’s love to particular people, not just declare it in words. “Merry Christmas” should mean more than an extra-special “Good day to you.”

As the state­ment ex­plains, the bless­ing ex­presses God’s love for hu­man­ity, which in­cludes help­ing hu­mans love other hu­mans. The bless­ing brings “in­clu­sion, sol­i­dar­ity, and peace­making. It is a pos­i­tive mes­sage of com­fort, care, and en­cour­age­ment. The bless­ing ex­presses God’s mer­ci­ful em­brace and the Church’s moth­er­hood, which in­vites the faith­ful to have the same feel­ings as God to­ward their broth­ers and sis­ters.”

More than our sins

As Francis has writ­ten, “We are more im­por­tant to God than all the sins we can com­mit be­cause he is father, he is mother, he is pure love, he has blessed us for­ever. And he will never stop bless­ing us.”

Advertise with us

That’s the God who gave us the baby and the story so many peo­ple love, whether they be­lieve or not, be­cause it speaks to the hope we have for the world, a world that sucks now, that love really is at the center of things.

David Mills is the as­so­ci­ate ed­i­to­rial page ed­i­tor and col­um­nist for the Pitts­burgh Post-Ga­zette: dmi­lls@post-ga­zette.com. His previous column was “Forget the college playoff scandal, read Vonnegut and feel better about the world.”