It’s a clown show, but not a funny one. The ambitious Kevin McCarthy abases himself to get elected Speaker, then stupidly makes an agreement that gives those who want his job an easy way to depose him. Which of course they do.

The clown show

The creepy Matt Gaetz positions himself as one of the most powerful people in Congress. A former moderate from South Carolina joins the rebels, apparently as a career move, and wears a shirt with a scarlet A on it claiming she’s been mistreated.

The rightwing Steve Scalise proves too liberal to get elected to replace McCarthy. The apparent next Speaker, Jim Jordan, denies that Joe Biden won several states, including our own. And even Jordan’s not a certainty, and if he is elected, who knows how long he’ll last?

Advertise with us

The establishment Republicans keep their heads down in hopes they won’t get blamed, and pray on their knees that this will all go away before they have to stand up to Donald Trump, which they have avoided doing for seven years.

We should be able to laugh, but we can’t. There’s a worrying lesson in that. The House Republicans have gone beyond ridiculousness into chaos, and chaos isn’t funny. It’s not funny for the same reason you don’t laugh when watching a train wreck: you can’t stop it and you know that it’s going to end in long-lasting pain and irreparable damage.

A serious political movement, however far out, you can make fun of. There’s something to hit, which means there’s something to engage or battle. You can’t hit chaos. It’s too confusing, too irrational, too many people following their egos and desires. You can only try to avoid being drawn into it.

Can you reason with a Gaetz or a Mace or a Scalise? Do you want them acting like this if the conflict in Israel spreads, or China invades Taiwan, or Russia uses nukes on Ukraine, or we’re hit with another pandemic? Are we really sure they could stop themselves when the nation needs them to? Chaotic people tend to stay chaotic — until they get control.

A sharp satire

Advertise with us

I thought of this after seeing the Pittsburgh Savoyards’ very entertaining performance of “Iolanthe” on its opening night last Friday. Gilbert and Sullivan’s seventh operetta, first performed in 1882, offers a light story of the encounter of the fairy world with ours, as in Shakespeare’s “A Midsummer Night’s Dream” or “Peter Pan,” but with a sharp satire of the English governing classes.

The Pittsburgh Savoyards have been putting on Gilbert and Sullivan shows for 86 years, and are the oldest continually operating theatre group in Pittsburgh. (The name comes from the theatre in London at which the shows were first performed.)

The productions take a year to put together and involve over 100 people, almost all volunteers, the production manager Lynette Garlan and the stage director Michael McFaden told me. They have many families who have joined in over generations. The people involved, they say, love it, and from what I’ve seen this is true.

They didn’t intend to perform a satire of the governing classes now. It just came up in the rotation. But, as they noted, almost all Gilbert and Sullivan’s works contain some satire of the powerful and rich.

The contrast between classes

Advertise with us

As I say, the contrast of the governing classes in “Iolanthe” with our own was notable. The story points to the nobility’s self-regard, for example. “Bow, bow, ye lower middle classes!” the lords sing, in unison and with force. “Bow, bow, ye tradesmen, bow, ye masses! ... We are peers of highest station, / Paragons of legislation, / Pillars of the British nation!”

The Lord Chancellor thinks of himself even more highly. He sings: “The Law is the true embodiment of everything that’s excellent. / It has no kind of fault or flaw, and I, my Lords, embody the Law!” He, in his forties, also has a thing for women under 21, which I think felt as icky then as it does now.

Gilbert’s own view, I think, is voiced by a lowly guard on duty at night outside Parliament. When the Members of Parliament vote, if they’ve got a brain, “They’ve got to leave that brain outside, and vote just as their leaders tell ’em to. / But then the prospect of a lot of dull M.P.’s in close proximity, / all thinking for themselves, is what no man can face with equanimity.”

The fairy queen puts one of their own into Parliament, magicking its members to vote for whatever he proposes. Strephon starts by making them stay in London during grouse and salmon seasons, and then raises city councilmen to the nobility, and — to the lords’ horror — decides to put people in the House of Lords by a competitive examination. They privately admit they’re not smart enough but insisted that had been a virtue in a lord.

There’s a good more of this in “Iolanthe.” You get the point. Gilbert could satirize the governing classes because they were, whatever their problems, serious and ordered enough to hit.

Advertise with us

The train wreck

We can only watch the Congressional train wreck with concern. But we can also watch an entertaining story from a better time, when politicians were coherent enough to be satirized, produced by people far more serious and orderly than Jordan, Gaetz et al.

The Pittsburgh Savoyards are, as I wrote last week, one of those treasures that make Pittsburgh Pittsburgh. “Iolanthe” will be performed three more times, this coming Friday, Saturday, and Sunday matinee, at the Andrew Carnegie Free Library in Carnegie.

David Mills is the associate editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: dmills@post-gazette.com. His previous article was “Why I became an evangelist for Pittsburgh.” Information on the Pittsburgh Savoyards’ production of “Iolanthe” can be found here.