He tried to poison his teacher. As a grad student at Cambridge University in the mid-twenties, Robert J. Oppenheimer put something into an apple — he told a friend he’d used cyanide — and left it for his tutor to find. A friend later said he’d been jealous of his teacher’s brilliance, good looks and popularity. Though he retrieved the apple before the tutor ate it, the university authorities found out.
Oppenheimer, of course, is the subject of the hit movie “Oppenheimer,” based on the biography “American Prometheus” by Kai Byrd and Martin J. Sherwin. The university naturally wanted to expel him.
No police, just counseling
His very wealthy parents happened to be visiting at the time, and his father negotiated with the university not to press charges. The authorities agreed to put the American student on academic probation as long as he went to counseling. It seems the police were never notified.
Almost anyone outside Oppenheimer’s rarified circles would have been arrested and tried for it. You and I would be. A working class Englishman of the time who’d put a poisoned apple on his boss’s desk would have been bunged off to jail for a long time without anyone thinking twice about it. Had Oppenheimer been treated like everyone else, as the law supposedly requires, his academic career would have been over.
His teacher, Patrick Blackett, later won the Nobel Prize in physics. He was also important in the defense against U-boats in World War II. Had Oppenheimer succeeded in murdering his teacher, he would have indirectly killed many others and changed history.
Read More
The pop science writer Malcolm Gladwell pointed to Oppenheimer’s good fortune in being so smart and so privileged — if that’s what it was, and I’m not sure — in his book “Outliers.” He contrasts Oppenheimer’s story with the story of someone who was at least as smart of he was, and maybe smarter. You can tell the same super-smart-kids stories of both them. They had the same amount of apparent promise.
A Telling Contrast
But Oppenheimer was Oppenheimer and Chris Langan someone you’ve probably never heard of. They had the same promise of greatness, but with two substantial differences: Chris Langan didn’t grow up the son of privilege with the best schooling imaginable and didn’t have wealthy, well-connected parents who knew how to work the system. Also, he didn’t try to poison his teachers, though his teachers actually mistreated him.
Langan grew up dirt poor with an alcoholic father. “We didn’t have a pair of matched socks,” he told Gladwell. “Our shoes had holes in them. Our pants had holes in them. We only had one set of clothes.” The brothers had to strip naked to wash their one set of clothes in the bathtub.
His father locked the food away in the kitchen and used a bullwhip to punish them. He’d disappear on drinking binges, lose jobs and move the family from town to town. One summer the family lived in a tent, surviving on government-surplus peanut butter and cornmeal.
He still got a scholarship to Reed College, an elite (and famously leftwing) school, but had to leave during the second semester because his mother, confused by the requirements, hadn’t sent in the financial aid form. The college wasn’t willing to help. He left before finals and got a F in every class.
He went home and started classes at a state university. When his car died, stranding him 13 miles outside town, the university refused to transfer him to afternoon classes he could get a ride to. “Well, son,” he reports his advisor saying, “after looking at your transcript at Reed College, I see that you have yet to learn that everyone has to make sacrifices to get an education. Request denied.” The dean agreed.
Langan, understandably, gave up and started reading and writing on his own. He might have been another Oppenheimer, but he didn’t have a chance.
Our national mythology
Americans tend to believe that you get what you deserve, for better or worse. It’s part of our national mythology — the idea that directs the way we look at the world and the judgments we make about people and things.
But we don’t necessarily get what we deserve, not all of it, anyway. Success doesn’t in itself indicate virtue and failure doesn’t in itself indicate vice. We know this from our own lives, knowing when we lucked out and when we got screwed.
There’s much to be said about this. One thing to say is that we should be very, very slow to judge those who haven’t succeeded, because we don’t know what they dealt with. And slow also to ascribe virtue to those who’ve succeeded, because we don’t know the breaks they got. We don’t know where anyone falls on the Oppenheimer-Langan spectrum.
Another is to be even slower to judge our own successes, because we don’t completely know the advantages we had. Always saying of others who haven’t done as well as you, “There but for the grace of God (or luck) go I” is a rule for a good life. It’s realistic about them, and it’s realistic about you.
David Mills is the associate editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: dmills@post-gazette.com. His previous article was “How to talk about ‘extremists’.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.