If anyone deserves to be beaten up in public, it’s fascists. It’s an ugly doctrine preached by ugly people, who want to see vulnerable people harmed, and have a taste for force and violence. Almost every political idea has a sunny side as well as a shadow side, some genuine good thing its advocates want, or fool themselves into thinking they want. Modern fascism doesn’t. It’s bad to the bone.
Scholars argue about what it is, whether it’s mainly an idea or a style of politics. I think it began as an idea with a style, but now it’s a style with an idea. The idea is that “we” are wonderful, but “they” are not us and our nation would be a better place were they not here. That’s married to the idea that we face extreme threats that require extreme remedies. “They” always includes Jews and racial and ethnic minorities.
The 43 Group
In the recent book We Fight Fascists, the historian Daniel Sonabend describes the 43 group, a group ofJewish war veterans who sometimes beat up fascists in public. They returned from fighting the fascists to find their British peers trying to gain political power and in the meantime to subjugate English Jews.
They weren’t going to take it. The group began when four friends drove past a small fascist rally on Hampstead Heath on the way to a pub that served Jewish ex-servicemen. They got to the pub, and encouraged by their peers, went back to the rally and beat up the speaker and his bodyguards.
They were experienced street fighters. The most Aryan-looking one (they knew their enemy’s weaknesses) went in first. He asked two of the bodyguards for a copy of their paper and dropped the change. “In the half-second in which the falling change caught the attention of the stewards,” Sonabend writes, “Len smashed their heads together.” They both slumped to the ground.
Read More
Another walked up to a steward and raised his fists. “The steward did the same. Beckman kicked him in the groin.” One of them thrashed the speaker.
It’s a great story, but not one to imitate.
The fascist’s leader
Sonabend’s book gives another example of how fascists tend to be suckered by charismatic figures. The English fascist movement was led by a man named Oswald Mosley, a wealthy man who owned a country estate and a yacht and — his beliefs were not so far from those common in his class — had created the British Union of Fascists in the 30s. He dreamed of being England’s führer. He exploited, and encouraged, the sadly common anti-semitic prejudice to do so.
The government had interned Mosley during the war, along with many of his followers. When released in 1943, he started in again to build a mass movement. This time, he tried to act more subtly. He told his followers not to attack “the Jews,” but to use code words like “aliens” and “international financiers.”
Mosley failed. In 1949, a disgruntled colleague described him in a resignation letter. “There is no ideology in your group,” he wrote. He seems to have meant that Mosley had beliefs, most of which we’d call bigotries, but no coherent set of ideas. But the beliefs had been enough to rouse the rabble that followed him.
As a result of having no “ideology,” his critic wrote, his followers “were never more than ‘Mosleyites’, i.e., political morons whose loyalty was to your person. ... Flattery and ability to bring good news only are the sole tests of loyalty.” His tiny number of followers were “of the lowest intellectual, spiritual and political calibre.”
Did they succeed?
Sonabend tells a fascinating story of a movement that began in the response of men loyal to their people and to the nation they’d risked their lives to serve, who recognized a real threat, and had the courage and — thanks to the British military and, ironically, Hitler — the skills to fight back.
They didn’t actually fight that much. For the most part, they went to fascist rallies and heckled the speakers until they gave up. They did fight when they had to, and that’s the story many people want to hear.
Did they succeed? Sonabend thinks so, but the story he tells doesn’t prove it. They damaged the British fascists’ abilities to get their message out through public rallies, but Mosley wouldn’t have gotten very far anyway, in a nation that had suffered so much from fascists. They may have cowed the fascists or extended their political life by giving them so visible an enemy.
He notes that the fascist appeal disappeared when the economy improved. English institutions proved, as they had in the 30s, resistant to such ideas.
I loved the story, not least because they beat up fascists. It’s so satisfying to see good men stand up. But it’s bad politics. We can’t deal with our own fascists, semi-fascists and would-be fascists the way they did. That way leads to more division and more violence — and more fascists.
David Mills is the associate editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: dmills@post-gazette.com. His previous article was “Jason Aldean's 'Try that in a small town' just feels fake.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.