One thing you can say for the Pittsburgh region’s politicians is that they’re simple. I mean that as a compliment. You know what they think and you know when some of them are being cagey about what they think, and the caginess stays within the usual bounds of political life. And when they lie, they lie for a reason, which is also within the usual bounds of political life.

Donald Trump isn’t simple. But he’s not complicated either. That would be okay. Complicated people you can figure out. Donald Trump is chaotic. And chaotic people create chaos, more of which the world does not need. I don’t think this has been discussed enough.

I haven’t worked through the details of his latest indictment, because who has time for that and what would it tell us we don’t know already? It seems to have been a typical example of the confusion in which — by which — he operates. He says whatever seems useful at the moment, whether or not it’s true or even plausible, and when he thinks he needs to say something else, contradicts himself without a second thought.

He just makes up stuff (like the magical mental declassification procedure) when he needs to defend the indefensible. He blames enemies (always) and even blames allies he may have just been praising (like his former press secretary Kayleigh McEnany). And sometimes, just to confuse us, he tells the truth. The result is a mass of claims that confuse everyone but the expert.

Advertise with us

He makes trying to understand what’s going on like walking through a dense fog in a forest. You will get lost. He wants you to get lost. Lost people can be more easily controlled, especially if you then claim to be able to guide them home. People living in chaos will follow someone who promises order — even if he’s the chaotic one.

President Biden, in contrast, when discovered to have a lot of classified documents he shouldn’t have had, some also stored with inadequate security, says sorry and gives them back. I wouldn’t rate his commitment to the truth very high, but it’s higher than Trump’s and when he lies, he lies, like the accomplished politician he is, for a reason.

Weirdly, even a politician’s lying can be a tribute to the political process and to the people: Biden plays fair by lying by the rules, giving everyone some chance to call him out. It’s a tribute to the public and political order. It’s saluting the rules even while breaking them. Not great, but much better than creating chaos.

Trump, as I’ve written before, lies the way the rest of us breathe. Trying to distinguish truth from falsehood as he speaks is like trying to sprint through an old-fashioned state fair funhouse, where every board in the floor tilts a different way and you quickly start reeling around till you fall down, and maybe can’t get up again. He creates chaos in the most essentially human space, our speech, where we try to communicate what we see of reality, which is hard enough as it is.

Creating chaos has worked for him. It helped elect him president. But now it’s not working and he can’t change. As Michael Wolff wrote in the New York Times, describing the end of Trump’s last campaign: He was “not a model chief executive but an inattentive, lazy, incompetent manager whose defiance of convention and hot mess of a personality were saddling his campaign with a heavy disadvantage.”

Advertise with us

He was being hugely outspent and outmaneuvered, but he didn’t do anything. “There is almost never any true plan, strategy or forethought in Trump world,” Wolff explained.  “Everyone around him lives in the prison of his monologues, which allow for no interruptions or reality checks and overrule any plans others have tried to make. His fixations, misunderstandings and contempt for better minds that might correct him reign.”

Can he change? The Renaissance philosopher Machiavelli would have said no, and he knew his politicians. “A man accustomed to follow one method, will never alter it,” he explained in his “Discourses.” Why don’t such people change? “We cannot act in opposition to the bent of our nature,” he said. Trump’s nature is bent toward chaos. And it has, alas, worked for him. When a man has succeeded doing what he does naturally, Machiavelli noted, “he can never be convinced that it is for his advantage to try some other.”

Donald Trump is who he is. And he’s not a nobody. He’s a former president who may be president again, who has a national audience whatever he says and does, who has tens of millions of supporters. But our world is too confused, too confusing, too chaotic to have someone so powerful who doesn’t care what is true, what is real.

David Mills is the associate editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: dmills@post-gazette.com. His previous article was “Nazis, Pharisees and people who hate.”