You gotta dance with the one what brung ya. It was a piece of folk wisdom when I was a kid, the sort of thing sold in highway rest stops, usually delivered in a dialect to make it sound more authentic. “Ve grow too soon alt and too late schmart” was another, on a plaque with fake Pennsylvania Dutch lettering.

Pennsylvania Republicans got to dance with the Trump what brought them. They may find that they get smart too late.

Dancing with Donald

Going into this spring, the Republican Party had a good chance of taking control of the Senate, but they couldn’t afford to lose any of the seats they had. In purple Pennsylvania, they needed to hold Pat Toomey’s seat come November.

They had a good shot at doing that, with all the advantages a midterm election gives the party out of power. All they needed was a conservative candidate whose character people would trust and whose positions would hold the base but appeal to the center.

Advertise with us

And what did they do? They did what, to be fair to the party, they had to do. They danced with the one what brought them.

But Donald Trump’s goals apparently aren’t theirs. They want to win. He secured the nomination of two weak candidates — Mehmet Oz in the Senate race and Doug Mastriano in the gubernatorial race — because they pledged themselves to him and his fantasy of being robbed of re-election. With that advantage, the two of them beat Republican candidates with a better chance than they of getting elected in November.

Mr. Mastriano might win, but he probably won’t, but losing the governor’s race leaves the party in the same place it is now, controlling the Legislature while having to negotiate with a progressive Democrat. The party has to win the Senate seat.

The Democrats even did them a favor by nominating a vulnerable candidate for the Senate. John Fetterman’s candidacy raises questions: about his health, which his carefully stage-managed campaign has only intensified; about the reasons he hides from the press (he hasn’t sat down for an interview in weeks); about his reported lack of interest in actually doing his job as lieutenant governor; about his real effect on Braddock, with some disputing his success story; about his radical positions, especially his opposition to fracking and his weird obsession with legalizing marijuana; about the gaps between his preaching and his practice; and about the extent to which his image as the unconventional rebel is a reality or a pose.

Donald’s candidates

But what did Mr. Trump lead the Republicans to do? They nominated his candidate, Mr. Oz, who is also a man with multiple vulnerabilities. And vulnerabilities a campaign as shrewd as Mr. Fetterman’s can exploit. His social media people have absolutely slaughtered Mr. Oz on the web.

Advertise with us

There’s the snake oil aspect of Mr. Oz’s TV career; the carpetbagging; his very recent conversion to conservatism and the pro-life cause; his extraordinary wealth (all those houses); his inability to look like one of us even when he tries (shopping for “crudités” at “Wegners” when clearly he’s never shopped for groceries); his inability to attract enough donors and get enough money; and the feeling many people have that he’s a performer, a fake, who for reasons unknown has decided he wants to be a U.S. senator and (temporarily) left New Jersey because Pennsylvania has an open seat.

Mr. Oz has so far run a train wreck of a campaign (the “Wegners” ad, for example). FiveThirtyEight’s poll shows Mr. Fetterman with a 9-point lead. And not because he’s become more popular. He had 48.2% of the vote on June 20th, and he had 48.2% of the vote on August 25th. Mr. Oz has lost 4 points in that time.

It’s surprising he hasn’t done worse. Though he still could. All he has going for him is the portion of the voting public that liked him as a TV celebrity, whatever influence Mr. Trump has, the money (lots) he can put into his own campaign, and a barrage of “End of the World, Fetterman is Satan” attack ads. The race should tighten, as races do, but Mr. Oz is very much a long shot.

But about the guy what brought them. Does Donald Trump care that his party take the Senate? Was electability a big part of his thinking when he chose to endorse Doug Mastriano and Mehmet Oz?

I have my doubts. Which helps him more in 2024: a Republican Party taking the Senate and keeping the Democrats from passing their bills, or a Republican Party not taking the Senate and letting the Democrats do what they want?

Advertise with us

The first doesn’t help him. The less the Democrats do, the less material he has to rouse his base and (since he surely thinks the Democrats will botch things) the less damage Democratic policies will do to the country. The second does help him.

The worse the country does, the more people will vote to make America great again.

Republicans can’t win either way. If Mr. Shapiro and Mr. Fetterman win, the Republicans will have blown a chance to win the governorship and a senator’s seat. They will have badly hurt their party’s chances to retake the Senate.

Donald’s magic

But what if one of the two Democrats proves to be a Hillary, capable of losing an election they had in the bag? Mr. Fetterman might, especially if his health proves to be enough of a problem to scare off voters.

If the Republicans win one of the elections, Mr. Trump will gain even more power over the party. He will have shown himself a political magician, and aspiring politicians will bow down before him, hoping he performs his magic on their behalf.

Advertise with us

But Donald Trump the political magician performs his magic for a reason, and it’s not the health and success of the Republican Party. It’s Mr. Trump’s own success. At some point, Republicans might see that, but they’ll be too late smart.

David Mills is the associate editorial page editor of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. He can be reached at dmills@post-gazette.com. His previous article was “Great baseball you probably don't know about.”