“There are more things in heaven and earth, Horatio, / Than are dreamt of in your philosophy.”
We live in a modern culture that considers itself uniquely broadminded: We survey reality from the hilltop of history, beneficiaries of centuries of political, economic and, above all, scientific progress.
Still, we are confronted today by events that confound us at least as much as they horrify us — and horrify us particularly because they confound us. The Western world, for all its progress and perspective, is bewildered as Russia uses tanks and missiles to try to force Ukraine into its fold.
The war is cruel and unjust, yes, but most of all it doesn’t make sense. Every day we see essays that try to explain what motivates Vladimir Putin.
Doesn’t he understand he has thrown a wrench into the (reasonably) well-oiled machine of the global economy? Doesn’t he care that Russia, and much of the rest of the world, will be poorer, no matter the outcome? And most of all, doesn’t he know that people don’t do this kind of thing anymore?
Well, first of all, they do. It’s been happening in Syria, Yemen and Ethiopia for years. But apparently war only rates as an anachronistic atrocity if fair-skinned people get up to it, west of the Urals.
More to the point, a worldview that can’t account for Vladimir Putin is seriously deficient, like a scientific theory that explains only half the data.
What most constrains the modern, enlightened mind is materialism. We can’t understand what we can’t conceive, and we can’t conceive of motives that go beyond profit and pleasure. The Russian president’s evocations of national glory and, from the “Third Rome” of Moscow, spiritual destiny don’t compute for us. That only proves how badly our imaginations have atrophied.
Our materialism is more than consumerism: It is an abiding conviction that nothing beyond what the senses comprehend is valuable, or real.
Strict materialism is a poor predictor of human behavior. Thomas Friedman wrote in his 2005 bestseller, “The World is Flat,” that “no two countries that are both part of a major global supply chain...will ever fight a war against each other.” Growing economic interdependence meant that the world was, in the ironic words of the British poet Philip Larkin, “going down the long slide / To happiness, endlessly.”
But that assumes that prosperity is the only, or at least primary, condition contributing to human happiness. People also need meaning and purpose, a sense they are part of something that transcends themselves, for and with others and through time and space — and beyond.
Materialism has left the West unable to fulfill its own people’s deepest needs or understand the motives of its adversaries. These intangible motives can cut both ways, toward dignity and heroism or cruelty and malice, but they are a constant of human nature that no amount of progress can suppress.
All of this will be thrown into particularly sharp relief on Friday. At the request of Pope Francis, Bishop David Zubik and the priests of the Diocese of Pittsburgh, along with clerics everywhere, will recite a prayer of consecration of Russia and Ukraine to the Immaculate Heart of Mary, entrusting these nations to her purity and strength.
For Catholics, this is no ordinary wartime petition. It is said that in 1917 in Portugal, the Blessed Mother appeared to three young children. Among her messages was an urgent request to consecrate Russia, or “she will spread her errors throughout the world, causing wars and persecutions of the Church.”
Catholics assumed then that Russia’s “errors” were communism and atheism; multiple popes have made acts of consecration (though it is a delicate matter, because the Russian Orthodox church thinks Russia is consecrated enough, thank you). Friday’s prayers, however, will be the first since the end of the Soviet Union, and the first joined by priests and bishops around the world.
In the context of Western materialism, this consecration is curious, at best. But you don’t have to believe the Virgin Mary chatted with Portuguese peasant children, or even be a Christian, to see the value in piercing the materialist veil. It’s now clear that the (unequally) shared prosperity of globalization won’t sustain a peaceful world order. And it’s clear, certainly in America, that a society needs more than cheap goodies to sustain vitality, unity and peace.
They won’t use the same words to describe it, but left and right agree that something invisible and intangible — something spiritual — is missing, or has gone haywire, in American society.
Competing in the new global order that emerges from the Ukraine crisis will require economic dynamism and geopolitical strategy. But it will also require rethinking the materialism that blinds us to realities that aren’t dreamt of in our philosophy.
Brandon McGinley is the deputy editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.