When one moves to Pittsburgh, some of what blows back the hair of the locals is easy to understand.

Kennywood, wedding cookie tables, the skyline view coming out of the Fort Pitt Tunnel — their allure and charm is instantly understood by all but the most cold-hearted.

Other quirks of the ’Burgh are a little tougher to figure, though. Why are natives who contemplate a move from the North Hills to the South Hills, or vice versa, the subject of emergency family interventions? Why can’t an East Ender love both Mineo’s and Aiello’s pizza? And what’s so great about a Clark Bar?

The last question is the subject today. The Boyer Candy Co. in Altoona brought back the sweet icon in time for Valentine’s Day, and Pittsburghers pounced on these long-lost bars for the “luscious core of crunchy golden goodness, just honeycombed with rich-tasting peanut butter, and a rich, chocolaty covering,” as the old ads put it.

Advertise with us

Katie’s Kandy in Fifth Avenue Place reported buying five cases of Clark Bars on Valentine’s Day. After I walked out of there with two bars at mid-day Monday, only two bars were left. Likewise, Giant Eagle/Market District spokesman Dick Roberts said limited quantities should be available this week, but he didn’t expect them to last long.

Some candy historians say the Clark Bar was the first “combination” candy bar. Irish immigrant David Lytle Clark had begun making candy in a North Side house in 1886, and then out of the D.L. Clark Building starting in 1911. That building that once churned out a million Clark Bars a day still stands just north of the North Side T Station, the only building from that era still standing between Heinz Field and PNC Park.

Candy manufacturing moved out of there to O’Hara in the mid-1980s. The financial finagler (and later convicted felon) Michael P. Carlow bought the brand when it was threatened with extinction in 1991. But Carlow’s check-kiting couldn’t keep the bar in Pittsburgh, and another manufacturer started manufacturing it in Illinois. After a brief comeback in O’Hara, the last bar was made there in 1999. The New England Candy Co. (perpetrators of those pasty Necco Wafers) made Clark Bars until the company shut down in 2018. Boyer bought the rights, recipe and equipment for the bar in September 2018. After a devil of a time getting the flavor, consistency and production just right, Clark Bars are back.

Even without having tasted one for decades — I’m a Snickers man myself — I knew Pittsburghers’ love for this candy bar defied comprehension. Back in 2000, when the Tribune-Review was operating out of the Clark Building and wanted to replace the big rooftop candy-bar sign with one of its own, a couple of City Council members tried to have the candy sign declared historic and block the Trib sign.

That seemed more unfair than the rocks in Charlie Brown’s trick-or-treat bag. While it was true that the Clark Bar was a delicious confection of corn syrup, cocoa and nuts, and the Tribune-Review lacked the corn syrup and cocoa, the newspaper was still manufacturing something. Why help the manufacturer that fled rather than the one that arrived?

Advertise with us

The Trib ultimately got its sign. (Ironically enough, given its editorials at the time, it was placed on the far left of the rooftop.) The Clark sign wound up gracing the parking lot across the street, where it still stands.

As for my first taste of a Clark Bar since I don’t know when?

I brought two back to my desk. (I wasn’t sharing. This was research.) I took a bite, then another. I felt the sweetness on my tongue. I felt a suddenly familiar sensation of gooey, crunchy peanut stuck on my back molars. I closed my eyes and felt myself back to the floor of my boyhood living room, my Halloween haul spread out on the floor, marveling at my loot and maybe making a couple of trades with my brother and sisters. And I’m enjoying this wonder called a Clark Bar.

I’m reasonably confident I will get my teeth clean again one day. Meantime, this bar sure has staying power. I guess I’m starting to understand what the fuss is all about.

Brian O’Neill: boneill@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1947 or Twitter @brotheroneill.