OK, so this is fake news. Not the first part, but the second.

Dominick Gambino, of McCandless, emailed me a few days after Valentine’s Day to say he’d been biking in North Park and had encountered a couple of abandoned pavilions in the woods that carried ancient carvings. He sent snapshots along.

One was from 1966. (Yes, that’s ancient. Ask any millennial.) The other was from 1995. Both showed hearts with the lovers’ names or initials inside.

The heart from ‘66 had “C.H.” and “A.H.” The one from ‘95 had “Beth & Mike 4 EVER.” Mr. Gambino suggested I run the images at the end of a column. Instead, I posted them on my personal Facebook page, asking, “Anyone know if C.H. and A.H., or Beth and Mike, are still a thing?”

Advertise with us

People immediately began paying my post the utmost respect.

“Charlton Heston + Alexander Haig,” Nat Hunter responded. “Who knew?”

I expected responses to continue in that spirit, but then Charlie Humphrey wrote: “It’s Greta Humphrey and Arthur Humphrey. Already married when this was carved.”

Wow. So what I thought was a “C” turned out to be a “G” for Greta. But then, remembering this was the internet circa 2020, I plaintively posted, “Is this truly theirs, Charlie?”

No, he confessed. But then making up family biographies has been a pastime for him. His post was a faint echo of one of the more inspired hoaxes in recent regional history. Mr. Humphrey was part of The Lost Pittsburgh School project that debuted in 2011.

Advertise with us

Brainchild of the actor David Conrad and others, The Lost Pittsburgh School was both a sendup of art criticism and a celebration of the quirks of a region too often dismissed as just another hole in the Rust Belt.

Mr. Conrad explained that he was inspired to begin the project about 15 years ago when he began noticing all the objects hereabouts that seemed to be pretty by accident. A car may have backed into a retaining pole and bent it, or how could we be sure that wasn’t “a beautiful piece of modern sculpture?” Mr. Conrad recruited the photographer Rob Larson, the poet Jim Daniels and other yinzer pranksters and the play began.

They shot hundreds of photos and invented characters — painters, sculptors, architects — and then asked a passel of writers to invent biographies for them. “People came back with the craziest stuff you’ve ever seen,” Mr. Conrad said.

It was a bit like the 1997 movie “Wag the Dog,” except nobody was faking a war in Albania to cover up a presidential sex scandal. They spent years building the story of “a true underground movement.” That’s how the novelist Stewart O’Nan described it in his deadpan July 2011 essay on The Lost Pittsburgh School for the PG’s Sunday opinion section. Mr. O’Nan said this week that he’d read Artforum for years, so copping the style and overwrought vocabulary of the art critic proved no trouble at all.

Speaking of the architects Dana Navratilova and Ryan Avedissian, for instance, Mr. O’Nan wrote: “While both were talented and original — even, some say, visionary — they share an uncompromising iconoclasm which didn’t mesh with the power brokers Downtown, and both, like The Lost Pittsburgh School itself, soon returned to the obscurity that defined the city.”

Advertise with us

In a boxed sidebar within that essay, Mr. Conrad wrote the key sentence that most read right past: Those architects, and everyone else named in The Lost Pittsburgh School, were not real. They were “imagined exemplars of an era, vehicles to help us reconceive what is art, and what is Pittsburgh.”

A climactic moment in the project came Aug. 13, 2011, at the UnSmoke Artspace in Braddock. Mr. Humphrey shared the tragic, violence-filled story of his father’s first cousin, Dexter “Dex” Humphrey III. Ol’ Dex owned a series of Buicks, lived on Amberson Avenue in Shadyside, and was a kind, gentle soul who charmed children but never had any of his own. “There was some speculation,” Mr. Humphrey wrote, “that maybe Dex lost more than a foot in the war.”

The project culminated with a big, square, hand-bound, hardcover book, “The Lost Pittsburgh School,” which still gets dropped in places such as the Ace Hotel in East Liberty. Those who pick it up can enter “this whole scene that didn’t exist,” Mr. Larson said. Or maybe, as in the works of J.R.R. Tolkien, “if enough people believe in it, it becomes kind of real.”

We’ve segued from this careful compilation of fake history into an era of idle, reckless charges of fake news. I find myself  hoping two things: That someone provides the full back story for Greta Humphrey and Arthur Humphrey, already married when that heart was carved in North Park 54 years ago. Or better, that the real G.H. and A.H. — or C.H. and A.H. — tell their story.

God still creates the best characters.

Brian O’Neill: boneill@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1947 or Twitter @brotheroneill.