For decades, two rival businesses on Murray Avenue have been doing their part to cloak Squirrel Hill’s business district in the unmistakable aroma of hot pizza.

Giovanni “John” Mineo opened Mineo’s Pizza House in 1958, and the restaurant has remained in the family for three generations. Giuseppe “Joe” Aiello was a Mineo’s employee who left after 12 years to open up Aiello’s Pizza in 1978, three doors away just up the block.

Both started out as small pizza parlors with humble beginnings and have grown to become world-famous, award-winning enterprises. Now, the pizzerias are each trying to grow their appeal to a broader customer base as they expand their size and offerings.

On St. Patrick’s Day 2014, Mineo’s opened a full bar and restaurant in a neighboring building that previously housed Engel’s Market. Aiello’s has begun construction on a similar venture in the building next door to its site that was formerly home to Zaw’s Asian Food.

Advertise with us

For John Mineo’s son, Dominic Mineo, who now runs the place, the bar and sit-down restaurant has been a great addition.

“The customers love the idea that they can come, sit and enjoy the great food that they’ve always had, but now they can have a beer or a mixed drink or a glass of wine with it,” Mr. Mineo said in a recent interview in his bar dining room. “It’s complemented the business. It’s been a win-win all the way around.”

Mike Aiello, who took ownership of Aiello’s after his father died in 2013, said he had the idea of expanding the establishment for years and seized the opportunity when Zaw’s closed at the end of 2015.

Construction was already underway early this year as Mr. Aiello anticipated a complete redesign of the interior of his restaurant. Plans included knocking out the wall that separated the two buildings, installing a bar, moving the kitchen away from the front entrance and adding more seating.

Mr. Aiello believes the expansion will generate more efficiency for his business. Since Aiello’s opened in 1978, customers have been funneled through the front door into a narrow space between the front counter and a wall, a space made even tighter with the addition of beer coolers.

Advertise with us

The space gets overcrowded as customers squeeze in during peak hours, leaving little working room for employees as orders keep rolling in.

“There’s no flow,” Mr. Aiello said at a booth in his restaurant around 9 one morning as he washed down fried cheese balls with an Orange Crush. “You got one guy making pizza; you got one guy cooking it; you have another guy answering the phone and collecting money; and you have another guy making hoagies and salads” all within a few feet of each other.

Mr. Aiello said he is expanding now, not because he has to but because he wants to offer more to the community.

But he admits that he is also expecting a revenue increase, particularly in beer sales.

Aiello’s bar will not serve liquor; it will have 10 to 16 taps for beer, many selections from local breweries. Monthly beer sales at Aiello’s before the installation of the bar were in the thousands of dollars, and Mr. Aiello said he believes that he can at least double that.

Advertise with us

Down the street, Mr. Mineo said the addition of the bar has boosted his revenue about 25 percent. He said the increase is due to the power that the bar has to bring people into the restaurant and keep them there longer.

“It’s going to increase revenue because there are people who are going to stay here and have a couple drinks while they’re having their pizza, their pasta, whatever they’re enjoying,” he said.

The Mineo’s bar has 12 beers on tap with five staples that include Guinness, Yuengling and a rotating light beer. Customers can get a whole pizza or other entree served to them while they’re sitting at the bar.

Like Mr. Aiello, Mr. Mineo said the expansion wasn’t a necessary move — the pizzeria can produce more than 100 pies an hour on a busy night — but one that has been a boon for business.

“It wasn’t needed to boost the business, but it was needed to enhance the business,” he said.

Advertise with us

Despite the long-term success, Mr. Mineo said that he wasn’t afraid to continue to try to grow the business.

“There’s always a risk — anytime you invest money into a business there’s always a risk,” he said. “But we’re on top of our business. We do everything the right way, and we work very hard for what we’ve accomplished. So I felt pretty confident that things were going to go well.”

As for Aiello’s development, Mr. Mineo says that he doesn’t pay much attention to what they do.

Emphasis on the “they.”

Same thing goes for Mr. Aiello, who, with a wink and a nudge, scolds visitors who dare mention the name of the pizza place down the street inside his restaurant.

Andrew Goldstein: agoldstein@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1352.