Froggy’s existed in another Pittsburgh.

Those of us who knew the place in the 1980s and ’90s all have tales about the venerable tavern whose namesake, Steve “Froggy” Morris, held court nightly at a round corner table. Now the owners of the brick building at First Avenue and Market Street that housed the bar have plans to take it and its neighbors down. The promised development includes an office building that could be as high as 22 stories.

Twenty-two stories? Froggy could tell that many before happy hour began.

Preservationists hope to halt the razing but the bar itself has been gone since 2003. The patrons who haunted the multi-storied joint are fading, too. I’d have sworn Froggy’s has been gone more than 16 years, it seems so tied to the last century.

Advertise with us

I still have a strong memory of Froggy in his crowded barroom, right after the culmination of the successful first Iraq war in 1991, with his big walrus mustache, big glasses and growling laugh bigger still. He was the Wisdom Table, surrounded by his cronies, and he shouted to me with his impish smile, “Saudi Arabia will be the 51st state!”

Right or wrong, Froggy said everything with gusto.

Yeah, Pittsburgh is punctuated with friendly neighborhood bars, and the South Side and Strip have plenty of places that lure in weekend party commandos, but a great Downtown bar is more difficult to pull off than a perfect martini. Froggy’s did it as well or better than any barkeep before or since, pulling in lawyers, secretaries, pro athletes, actors, umpires, reporters and other scoundrels, everyone feeling strangely at home.

Nobody was more at home there than the owner, though. He just loved saloons, always did, as is evidenced by this story he shared with me long ago.

In the summer of 1963, he was 19, a big strong kid who’d just gotten off a freighter that had come into the port of New York. It was easy to get seaman's papers back then, and he’d spent the better part of a year sailing to Australia, Hong Kong, Singapore, Madagascar, South Africa and Sicily.

Advertise with us

So he had a pocketful of money in P.J. Clarke’s in midtown Manhattan, and he’d spent enough to fall into a heated argument with the fellow who’d just stood him a drink.

Froggy — he got the name from his raspy voice — had been reading voraciously on that boat, you see, and like so many young American men of the time, his literary hero was Ernest Hemingway.

After he and this older guy had bought each other a round, the other fellow started lecturing him about Hemingway. Froggy, drunk enough to know everything, tried to tell the guy the real story about the great writer, but the man wouldn’t shut up.

So Froggy finally told him, “You don’t know anything about Ernest Hemingway!” (Though he used a more colorful word than “anything”.)

The stranger had been an amateur boxer but, seeing before him a guy who was bigger (Froggy would later play offensive line at Pitt), drunker and louder, he stormed out.

Advertise with us

What a jerk, Froggy said (or words to that effect).

That’s when the bartender told him he’d just chased off Norman Mailer. Maybe you’ve heard of him. The novelist had written “The Naked and the Dead” in 1948 and, after he left Froggy behind, he wrote books that won him a couple of Pulitzer Prizes and a National Book Award.

That only made it a better story to tell. I later read this line from Mailer: “Fame was the inability to get boozed anonymously in a strange bar.” So I guess he remembered Froggy, too.

Mailer outlived Froggy, who lived hard and died too young at 62 in July 2008, after suffering from emphysema and other ailments. In my mind’s eye, though, I can still see him at The Wisdom Table, talking above the roar of his crowd.

“You know what I like best about this place?” he said to me there one elbow-to-elbow night.

Advertise with us

“No,” I said. “What?”

“I own it,” he said, and lifted another glass of icy brown liquid.

Brian O’Neill: boneill@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1947 or Twitter @brotheroneill