It was all very “Wild, Wild West,’’ these lavish private railroad cars parked on the tracks in the heart of Oakmont during the U.S. Open last month, and I was pleased to come aboard.
They belonged to the Iowa Interstate Railroad, co-owned by Pittsburghers Henry Posner III and Bob Pietrandrea, whose Railroad Development Corp. runs freight and passenger railroads from Peru to Germany to Iowa. My cousin, in from Philadelphia because her husband’s a golf fan, and I were among the railmen’s guests.
We walked through the plush Hawkeye office car to the Abraham Lincoln dining car, where 10 tables under white linen were laid out for 40 diners. It seemed such a throwback, my cuz said she expected Bing Crosby and Rosemary Clooney to show up any second. I’m an unabashed rail fan but was strictly an amateur amid this company. As the wine flowed and shrimp vanished, I fell into conversation with a mileage collector.
Yeah, I’d never heard of the hobby before either, but Chuck Weinstock, 68, of Squirrel Hill, is among a countless number of rail mileage counters. He has rolled through parts of all 50 states.
Not even Amtrak hits every state. Yet in a country that has chronically neglected its passenger rail despite increasing demand, Mr. Weinstock and dozens of his friends have managed to find passenger excursions where regular passenger lines stopped rolling decades ago.
After our meeting, Mr. Weinstock emailed his rail map of Pennsylvania, marked with more red lines than a drunk’s eyes, showing where he’d been. I asked him to lunch to tell me more.

When he was a boy in suburban Chicago, he’d go with his mother to pick up his father getting off the commuter train pulled by an enormous (to a kid) steam engine. Decades later, as a graduate student at Carnegie Mellon University in 1974, he walked into a Downtown hobby shop and found an ad for a four-day excursion over the Fourth of July weekend led by the Norfolk & Western and Southern Railway.
The trip from Cincinnati to Roanoke and Alexandria, Va., included two nights in the grand Hotel Roanoke and cost only $119. But he had to spring for another 24th of that to buy a $5 tie at a five-and-dime in little Mullens, W.Va., or he couldn’t be seated in the Hotel Roanoke restaurant. There no man is allowed to slurp the famed peanut soup without a tie to keep it interesting.
Such slices of Americana are what keep Mr. Weinstock on trains. Unlike most mileage collectors, some of whom claim 200,000 rail miles, he doesn’t actually count the miles. He just marks the routes in red. Ask him where he’s ridden in Maine or Montana and he’ll call up the state map from his laptop.
At this point, he says, it’s more about being with old friends than accumulating miles. He took a charter excursion last month longer than the cattle drive in “Lonesome Dove,’’ this one from Texas to Minnesota by way of New Mexico, Colorado, Wyoming, Montana and North Dakota. He knew virtually all of the 60 to 80 riders on the 2,400-mile trip, many of them since the 1980s, and picked up about 650 miles new to him. One 78-mile stretch in Montana hadn’t seen a passenger train since 1925.
This is no inexpensive hobby. Mr. Weinstock always has booked sleeping cars for overnight trips; he’s never tried sitting upright through the night like Kenny Rogers’ “Gambler.” He’ll make a half-dozen trips a year, anywhere from a day to a week, more often by special excursions than via Amtrak.
The irony is Mr. Weinstock often flies to the starting points. The Amtrak backwater that is Pittsburgh has only one daily train in any direction. Though he likes taking the Capitol Limited from Washington to Pittsburgh, the train from here to D.C. leaves at 5:20 a.m.
About 15 years ago, he and some Software Engineering Institute colleagues began booking Yellow Cab round trips with the legendary taxi driver Bill Lenhart because his rates and times beat either flying or taking the train to Washington. Mr. Lenhart died in 2005, but those taxi pools remain a good deal and continue on through a group of Yellow Cab drivers Mr. Lenhart helped organize.
Only in America could accumulating train mileage be such a novelty. Amtrak needs more trains.
Brian O’Neill: boneill@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1947.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.