"Mistakes were made."
Is there a more weaselly phrase in the political language? Does any have more bipartisan appeal?
Mayor Luke Ravenstahl is the latest to employ what has been called the "past exonerative" tense, describing disgraced City Councilwoman Twanda Carlisle's felonious exit from city hall this way:
"It's an unfortunate day in many ways, and it gives us in city government a black eye. We need to make sure that, in the future, we avoid situations like this. I wish Councilwoman Carlisle the best in the future but, the reality was, and she acknowledged today, mistakes were made, and there are repercussions for those mistakes."
I suppose one could say the mayor was being as kind as possible to a colleague on the worst day of her life. Ms. Carlisle pleaded no contest to 17 charges, including ethics violations, and resigned. The mayor, when he was council president, got the wheels of justice turning by referring the matter to the city solicitor, who referred it to the district attorney. Yet, in the end, the mayor chose modern political double talk rather than the naked truth. He should have said something like:
"She's a crook. Ms. Carlisle abused the public trust in order to enrich herself with tens of thousands of taxpayer dollars that she did not earn, for possessions as crass as a mink coat she did not need.The good people of her district recognized this by defeating her soundly in last spring's primary, and they will be served far better by the new councilman they elected this month, the Rev. Ricky Burgess."
Instead, we got "mistakes were made," a construction designed to make us think mistakes have lives of their own, that nobody makes them, that these unnatural occurrences victimize people all by themselves.
The dodgy device is so prevalent it inspired a recent book: "Mistakes Were Made (But Not By Me): Why We Justify Foolish Beliefs, Bad Decisions and Hurtful Acts" by Carol Tavris and Elliot Aronson. (In that spirit, I confess the book was read, but not by me.)
Wikipedia, the free Web encyclopedia that anyone can edit, has a long "Mistakes Were Made" entry. It's defined, in part, as a way in which the speaker "seeks to evade any direct admission or accusation of responsibility by using the passive voice." The fault is kept abstract with "no direct reference to who made the mistakes."
President Richard Nixon was a great one for this trick, though he eventually came around to "I am not a crook." Neither served him well.
President Ronald Reagan used a variation in a State of the Union Address in 1987 back when we were trading arms to the Iranians for flimsy promises to get American hostages released in Lebanon. (That was when our president advanced the idea of "Iranian moderates," a concept that turned out to be about as productive as "Khomeini Lite.")
Mr. Reagan said: " ... we did not achieve what we wished, and serious mistakes were made in trying to do so. We will get to the bottom of this, and I will take whatever action is called for."
He didn't earn his tag "The Great Communicator" that night.
More recently, our erstwhile, memory-challenged U.S. attorney general, Alberto Gonzales, used the phrase as he tried to explain away the firing of eight U.S. attorneys:
"I acknowledge that mistakes were made here. I accept that responsibility."
His boss, President Bush, echoed him: "He's right, mistakes were made. And I'm, frankly, not happy about it because there is a lot of confusion over what really has been a customary practice by the presidents."
Yes, there is confusion. What were the mistakes and who made them? Nobody could say, but they were made, yeah boy, there's no denying they were made.
If there is a more evasive phrase in government it's the one Ms. Carlisle used in court on Tuesday. She pleaded "no contest" to the charges she took kickbacks from staffers.
Ah, "no contest," those two little words that say so much when they try to say so little. What they say is, "Damn it, you caught me. I'm not going to plead guilty because I haven't the character to take responsibility."
In her brief letter of resignation, Ms. Carlisle said she "enjoyed my service to our city and its residents."
We figured that out from the mink, but what citizens sought was an apology. None came. There's no mistaking that.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.