WASHINGTON, D.C. — The ridges looked like gentle waves cresting in the mist, all the way to the fiery horizon. I knew no photograph could capture it, so I had to commit the image to memory, and hope that words could do it some justice.
I received a wonderful, surprise gift this week: perfect evening weather for a flight to the nation’s capital. The experience put Pittsburgh in its unique geographic context in a way nothing else can, especially the tension between how close we are to the power centers of the Great East, yet how strange and separate we are in the rugged plateau on this side of the mountains.
I’ve written and had several conversations about regional economic development in recent weeks. Some people talk about young boomtowns like Columbus and Nashville and Austin as models. I prefer what I call regional peers, like Cleveland and Cincinnati and Milwaukee, older cities of roughly similar size that experienced the trauma of deindustrialization, though not to the extent we did, and have rebounded more successfully from the pandemic.
Yet from the air, it becomes clear that while Pittsburgh can learn from all of them, its future will be, and was always going to be, in embracing its distinctive place in the world. In being the best Pittsburgh it can be.
The first frontier
Wednesday evening was perfect. On takeoff I oriented myself by catching the Cherrington Office Park, then the tumbling Montour Heights Golf Club, then Coraopolis and Neville Island. Then, of course, it was the Golden Triangle itself, whose remarkable setting tucked into the deepest gouge in the high plateau can only really be appreciated from this vantage.
I tried to pick up Brookline, but the neighborhoods between the ravines all run together when you only have 30 seconds to sort them out. Then I traced the Parkway West to Interstate 79, which appears (rightly) as an essential corridor of activity from above, in a way it doesn’t so much from the ground. Southpointe, Canonsburg, Washington. I suspect Pittsburgh-to-Morgantown will only become more important in the years to come.
The Mon Valley was next. The Mon-Fayette Expressway bridge was below as we crossed the river, leading to Uniontown. It all doesn’t feel so forlorn from the air, and you can hope that someday the area’s natural advantages will win out over its industrial collapse.
It’s at the sudden rise of Chestnut Ridge, the first of the Allegheny Mountains to Pittsburgh’s east, that everything changes. I know it isn’t as dramatic as the Front Range of Colorado, but it serves the same purpose for us. It’s when you realize that all the places you’ve just admired are perched on the edge of what God intended to be, and largely still remains, a great wilderness. This separates the first frontier from the eastern plains.
Going east
We curled around Deep Creek Lake, the all-season playground of western Maryland, and then it was ridge after ridge after ridge, many topped with a dot-by-dot of wind turbines, but each with its own distinctive shape. I wish I could identify them (I was looking for the high meadows of Dolly Sods, but they were on the other side of the plane), but at the same time one mustn’t delve too deeply into the mysteries of West Virginia.
Finally, we emerged beyond the ridges, beginning with Winchester, Va., and the elegant Shenandoah Valley — the buffer between the Great East and Appalachia. After one last strip of highlands, our destination came into view: Northern Virginia, land of data centers, fulfillment centers, lifestyle centers, all kinds of centers, which even from above are sterile and soulless.
It is the physical manifestation of the kind of power that emanates from the capital, calculating and characterless. As much as the mountains detach Pittsburgh from the benefits of proximity to power, they also protect us from a certain kind of corruption.
The final dramatic descent into Washington-Reagan renewed my spirits, and I quietly rattled off landmarks I’ll always love even as the nation they honor feels more like one of the past than of the future.
Being ourselves
In Washington, though, my thoughts turned back to home, and the lessons of the beautiful aerial overview I was privileged to enjoy.
Brian O’Neill famously christened Pittsburgh the “Paris of Appalachia,” but I don’t think the importance of this perfect little description has ever fully sunk in.
For better or for worse, we can’t and won’t ever be Loudon County, Va., or Nashville with its southern laissez-faire business culture or even Cleveland with its access to the Great Lakes. We can learn from them, but each of these places thrives, to the extent they do so, by pressing their own place-based advantages.
Pittsburgh, on the other hand, has too often been embarrassed about its place in the world — its Appalachian heritage, its ocean of subterranean fossil fuels, its perfect-for-industry geography. This has led to a desire to be something we’re not, to attempt to mimic other cities’ and regions’ successes rather than to aggressively pursue our own destiny.
Pittsburgh can be a great tech hub, for instance, but it won’t be a generic tech hub. It will be the kind of tech hub that deploys massive amounts of local energy (including renewables like wind), that leverages access to water, that uses its distinctive geography, like its riverfront brownfields, to full effect.
At this political and economic inflection point, the region is crying out for leaders and institutions who are unconstrained by ideological and cultural embarrassment. Who have the vision not to chase fads or to mimic peers. Who are ready to carve out of this Appalachian landscape the thriving region that’s just beneath the surface, like a masterpiece in marble.
Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “Finding hope amid the long defeat of history.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.