For Pittsburgh demographic data nerds, it’s like Christmas Day and a kick in the shins rolled into one: the annual release of new county-level population estimates. As usual, the numbers are fascinating and discouraging.

Also as usual, I am indebted to University of Pittsburgh researcher Chris Briem for collecting this data in a coherent way and posting it on social media.

Here’s the tale of the tape for the Pittsburgh region: decent domestic in-migration (people moving here from elsewhere in America), about middle-of-the-road compared to other top-40 metros; overall population decline of 0.13%, ranking fourth-worst; and the kicker, natural population decline (deaths versus births) of 0.32%, making the region one of only five with more deaths than births and by far the worst off.

It’s this last number that’s a parachute southwestern Pennsylvania is dragging as it seeks the elusive goal of economic and demographic growth. And it’s the same figure as last year, forcing me to ask the same question I posed 12 months ago: Is Pittsburgh doomed?

Advertise with us

Positive momentum

In that column, I proposed five concepts or conditions that will be essential to Pittsburgh turning the corner, along with a final challenge: aim for 5% aggregate population growth by 2050. Let’s attempt a progress report.

Pittsburgh must capitalize on its strengths. The region is far richer in natural and institutional resources than its peers. But we’ve struggled to turn those advantages into growth.

In this regard, U.S. Sen. Dave McCormick’s Pennsylvania Energy and Innovation Summit at Carnegie Mellon University last summer was a clear step in the right direction. The event directly addressed ways to deploy Pittsburgh’s strengths and presented them to some of the world’s most powerful political and financial leaders. Further, the biggest Pittsburgh-area announcement at the summit appears to be actually happening: a $3.2 billion bid by the Frontier Group of Companies to bring 3.6 GW of power generation and a data center complex to Shippingport, Beaver County.

There’s a lot more to be done, but McCormick created a new template, and demonstrated a new level of ambition, that Pittsburgh should learn from.

The future is for-profit. Pittsburgh has uniquely strong non-profit and philanthropic sectors, for which it should (mostly) be grateful, but they can’t drive an economy on their own.

Advertise with us

The biggest corporate announcement of the past year was Eos Energy’s choice to locate its headquarters in Pittsburgh, along with a $353 million investment in local manufacturing. The innovative battery-maker has hit some headwinds in the stock market, but it remains a potentially massive beneficiary of electrification.

This is good news. But celebrating it too much is like raising a “playoff participant” banner in your arena while your competitors are vying for a championship. Landing a deal like this is the baseline for economic development, not a crowning achievement.

In government, meanwhile, Mayor Corey O’Connor’s direct outreach to businesses and his early commitment to permitting reform demonstrates a major change in the city’s posture toward the private sector. This should eventually bear fruit.

Inside and outside

New regional leadership groups must arise. Last year I singled out the Allegheny Conference on Community Development as a legacy institution structurally unsuited to the present moment. This week I attended the group’s Annual Meeting, and my view hasn’t changed.

In fairness, these kinds of gatherings are difficult to make interesting. (“They’re always boring,” one veteran quipped.) And the city should be grateful for CEOs who are willing to moonlight as civic champions, as Highmark’s David Holmberg has during his tenure chairing the conference’s board.

Advertise with us

But the room felt full of people attending out of obligation, not enthusiasm. Many left before the end of the program.

More importantly, the most invigorating conversations I have with people trying to reshape Pittsburgh are invariably with those working outside established channels. Somehow, the energy percolating outside the room is going to have work its way inside, or coalesce into a force of its own.

Pittsburgh will look very different. While municipal consolidation remains a pipe dream for now, there is clearly momentum for zoning and land use reform in the City-County Building. O’Connor’s pro-growth appointments to the Planning Commission, in particular, signal a willingness to consider policies and regulations that loosen the city’s unusually strict development and land-use rules.

This process will force Pittsburghers to choose between a comforting but stagnant languor and a creative but challenging dynamism. Having a comforting baby-kissing mayor may help make a changing city more palatable.

The city will likely need a single leader. This person who cuts through Pittsburgh’s Gordian knot of civic complications doesn’t have to be, and probably won’t be, an elected official. O’Connor’s hands are full managing the mess he inherited, and his strengths tend toward retail politics rather than grand strategy and arm twisting.

Advertise with us

Napoleon famously said at his coronation that he found the crown of France in the gutter. Pittsburgh isn’t in the market for a rapacious emperor, but it does feel like regional leadership is available for the taking.

Inflection point

On most of the five points, Pittsburgh is in a better place today than it was last year. I feel in myself and sense in others an optimism that was absent 12 months ago.

Unfortunately, the Pittsburgh region has slightly retreated from my 5%, or 120,000-person, growth target for 2050. Yet it is in the nature of civic evolution and economic development that structural changes take a while to manifest statistically.

So no, I still don’t think Pittsburgh is doomed, and yes, I do think real growth is possible. While natural population decline is a challenge, we can manage the migration needed to overcome it. The question is whether the modest momentum generated over the past year has been a brief lurch in the right direction, or is the beginning of a more serious, intentional, structural pro-growth politics for Pittsburgh.

Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “How did Pittsburgh’s finances get so bad, so quickly?”