In every nook and cranny in the City-County Building, the O’Connor administration has seemingly found hidden costs and overstated revenues left behind by the Gainey years — but not only by them.

In fact, Mayor Corey O’Connor’s press conference last week announcing the reopening of the budget to address a shortfall of at least $40 million tactfully left many discoveries unmentioned, presumably to avoid appearing to blame his predecessor too aggressively.

Or because the scale of the financial mismanagement was so massive as to be incredible.

Since then, I’ve noticed an increase in public comments and private remarks suggesting that the blame for Pittsburgh’s financial mess should be spread more evenly. Are not City Council and the Controller’s Office independently elected branches of government, responsible for checking mayors whose governance is setting back the city? Isn’t the problem bigger than one mayor?

Advertise with us

They are, and it is. But they’re not the only ones responsible for holding the mayor accountable.

Minimal incentives

The extent of the collapse of Pittsburgh’s finances in just the past few years should be considered a systemic failure: The checks and balances didn’t work, and by the time the voters had their say nearly a year ago, much damage had already been done.

Yet city officials’ leverage depends on a third check on the power of the executive in Pittsburgh’s strong mayor system: the public. And the public’s ability to act as such a check depends on local news media. It is their job to poke around Grant Street and inform the public about the workings of its government — especially the workings, or non-workings, hidden in complicated spreadsheets and dense reports.

The threat of public rebuke, and ultimately defeat at the polls, is the strongest incentive in favor of prudence and integrity. But when the press has withered, and the public’s attention is dissipated, the system can’t function as it should.

There’s no doubt that City Council in particular could have stepped in before the eleventh hour. The legislature approves every expenditure, and was empowered to vote down Gainey’s “affordable housing” bond or “community engagement” for the comprehensive plan or dodgy 2024 and 2025 budgets that set stage for the 2026 budget fiasco.

Advertise with us

Council also added unnecessary expenditures of its own, including $3 million for “food justice” and $1 million to buy medical debt, way beyond the scope of a cash-poor city’s duties.

The problem is that councilmembers didn’t realize Pittsburgh had become cash-poor until far too late, mostly because they trusted the guidance they were receiving from the executive branch. As a body, council has a single budget director and a skeletal policy staff. Individually, members have three staffers whose primary responsibilities are constituent services, not investigating executive-branch hijinks.

As early as July 2023, I wrote in these pages that council needed to stand up to the mayor, but the incentives its members needed to make that choice were not yet available.

Limited powers

Which brings us to the Controller’s Office. Rachael Heisler took the helm at the beginning of 2024, bringing a renewed vigor to the office’s watchdog role, with a particular emphasis on exposing the Gainey administration’s false budget assumptions.

Yet it is worth asking if the controller could have done even more, especially in uncovering the executive’s unpaid bills. How, for instance, did Gainey avoid paying the city’s water bill for an entire year?

Advertise with us

This gets at the inherent limitations of the Controller’s Office. Heisler is required by law to process any approved invoice sent to her office. She can throw a flag if she finds something amiss, but her enforcement powers are basically nil.

If the executive fails to transmit an invoice to her office, she wouldn’t know it exists. It may be fair to argue that Heisler should have noticed the absence of the water invoices, and that her office should be more attentive to what the mayor is not sending along.

But here’s the thing: In November of last year, Heisler did mention the unpaid water bills in a City Council budget hearing — and apparently no one noticed. This gets at the second limitation on both the controller and council: If they do perform their watchdog roles, and the public neither notices nor cares, because the media doesn’t inform them, does it even matter?

Our responsibility

In a strong mayor system like Pittsburgh’s, the checks-and-balances system is strained when neither of the branches of government meant to rein in the executive can trust its word or intentions. And it breaks down entirely when the third watchdog — the public, informed by the press — is inattentive.

Now, it’s fair to say that council in particular, given its legal authority to approve or disapprove city spending, could have done much more to protect the city’s pocketbook during the Gainey years.

Advertise with us

But both branches ultimately depend on the institution between them and the people — the news media — to ensure their work applies public pressure to the executive. When the number of journalists is decreasing and their own incentives to hold a mayor accountable are mixed, it reduces the incentive for elected officials to perform their watchdog roles aggressively.

When the news media is weakened, so are the incentives for the executive branch to behave itself, and for its elected counterweights to take risks to hold it accountable. This is the crux of the systemic failure that allowed Pittsburgh’s finances to go from stable to critical in just a few years — even though it eventually kicked in, in the form of an election.

We can always ask more of our elected officials, who accept a public responsibility when they run for office. But without a robust news media dedicated to covering the affairs of Grant Street, the accountability system becomes very fragile, very quickly — and Pittsburgh goes millions of dollars further in the hole.

Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “How to stay sane in crazy times.”