Pittsburgh’s era of optimism lasted a little less than a decade. It began in 2009 with the G-20 summit, when national and international journalists reported from the Golden Triangle that Pittsburgh was a hidden gem whose value was about to skyrocket. Pittsburgh was poised, it seemed, to be one of America’s it-cities for the age of knowledge-work.
For the first time in two generations, we could imagine something other than managing decline. New flights at the airport. An arena district on the horizon. Downtown reinvigorated. Lawrenceville transformed. UPMC on top of the Steel Building. Uber’s autonomous vehicles. Google’s regional office.
Pittsburgh had a seat at the grown-up table again. Sixteen years later, not only has Pittsburgh been relegated, but several peers have passed us on the depth chart, including Ohio’s three C’s.
It would be easy to say Pittsburgh lost its mojo due to the pandemic, but that was a shared shock. It was actually two years earlier, in 2018, when in the first major test of our potential as an emerging economic powerhouse, we didn’t just lose: We were embarrassed.
Renewed trauma
In retrospect, it was absurd to think Pittsburgh could win Amazon’s HQ2 competition. But at the time, riding that decade of enthusiasm, it seemed plausible the next step could be a great leap.
Not getting picked was one thing, but it was clear regional leaders had tossed all the eggs into the HQ2 basket, including offering more incentives than any other region in the country. And still we barely got a look. Plus, the bid’s secrecy led to scandal at home, making the whole thing seem tawdry.
We’d screwed up the courage to enter the big-city beauty pageant, and we were laughed out of the room. It seemed to confirm that the low-ambition, risk-averse, aim-small-miss-small, managed-decline approach was right all along. The post-steel trauma was back: Better to putter along in mediocrity than to risk embarrassment by trying (again) to carve out a new place for ourselves in the marketplace.
The mayoralty of Ed Gainey was part of this turning-inward, and deepened it. Elephant-hunting for game-changing economic development partners was out; “affordable housing” and “disparity studies” — not bad in themselves, but a radically incomplete vision of governance — were in.
It has been a first principle of this administration that economic growth and development are inherently suspicious, that Pittsburgh has nothing of value from which the city could benefit by offering to the market, and that anyone who suggests otherwise is a profiteer.
This suited much of the city’s old guard just fine. Still weighed down by the post-steel malaise, they’re accustomed to thinking of the city as a closed system — an island buoyed against rough and rising seas by billions of foundation dollars, in need of nothing from the outside that might introduce new risk or upset the balance of power.
Changing course
Which brings us to the presumptive next mayor, Corey O’Connor.
Few would describe the long-time city pol with a boyish face and a cheerful demeanor as a naturally aggressive disruptor of the status quo. But that’s exactly what he’s going to have to be if he’s going to succeed.
What Pittsburgh needs right now, at least as much as it needs pro-growth urban policy and a robust economic development strategy and a culling of unnecessary rules and regulations, is an attitude adjustment.
It needs a mayor who proposes and embraces big and bold ideas, and pushes them through regardless of ideological caterwauling. It needs a mayor who passes over some legacy stakeholders and institutions who may have civic stature, but no longer have a track record of producing civic solutions. It needs a mayor who empowers, both in and out of government, a new cohort of young, ambitious, creative leaders who aren’t beholden to established systems and people; who aren’t constrained by the post-steel neuroses; who are willing to suggest ideas, and to try to see them through, that challenge Pittsburgh’s pieties; who don’t care if “it’s always been done” some other way.
It needs a mayor who isn’t afraid to be great, in order to help Pittsburgh fulfill the potential for greatness within itself.
Choosing greatness
This week I spoke with a Downtown property developer who recently scouted the urban core of a competing city. The verdict: If he had been invested there, and then visited here, he would want to move all his capital to Pittsburgh.
This is a city aching to be great. It has great universities, great museums, great theaters, great architecture, great geography, great history, great neighborhoods, great civic pride, great people.
What it doesn’t have are the great leaders to put it all together into a complete package: a great city that strategically deploys all its assets to compete confidently in the marketplace, and to grow so those assets can fulfill and enhance their greatness by being made available to more people.
Amazon’s HQ2 may have been a mirage, but Pittsburgh’s potential is not.
For Pittsburgh to be great, it needs leaders who put aside the fear of disruption that’s been so ingrained in this city’s culture, which is ultimately a fear of failure that ensures mediocrity, discourages ambition and chases away talent.
If Mr. O’Connor wishes to succeed at all, to be remembered as anything more than a placeholder or caretaker of managed decline, he has no choice: He must dare to be great.
Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “Take away your kids’ screens to save their summers.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.