During a Thursday press conference releasing Pittsburgh’s 2024 annual financial report, City Controller Rachael Heisler used the optimistic word “manageable” to describe the city’s fiscal situation.

That was an understatement, but reporting on the City of Pittsburgh’s finances, whether as the city’s official fiscal watchdog or as a member of the media, is a delicate matter. The prime directive to tell the truth, no matter what. But in telling the truth, we can use a variety of adjectives and adverbs, each of which communicates a different level of urgency.

There’s a risk that the audience — that is, the people of the city — won’t consider the truth to be credible if it’s presented too starkly. And this would undermine the purpose of telling the truth in the first place.

But in this case, I fear Ms. Heisler’s admirable discretion may have left a false impression. Pittsburgh’s future — especially that of its middle class — is gravely threatened. And there is strong evidence in the early financial returns from 2025 that the city’s economy is contracting at this very moment.

Advertise with us

The numbers

Here’s the gist of the problem. For the year 2024, the city budgeted for a $28 million operating surplus. Then, as revenues came in lower than expected, that surplus dwindled over the course of the year. The 2025 budget, compiled last fall, “estimated” that the 2024 surplus would be down to $18 million.

But Ms. Heisler’s annual report shows that even that was far too rosy: The audited final result for 2024 was only $4 million.

Now, you might think that doesn’t sound so bad. At least the city’s still taking in more than it spends! But the operating surplus doesn’t cover everything the city must pay for.

Out of that surplus comes $22.5 million in legally required transfers to trust funds: $10 million for Stop the Violence, $10 million for Housing Opportunity and $2.5 million to pay for the “affordable housing bond” floated last year. On top of that is so-called “paygo” money, which is how the city pays for capital projects, like parks upgrades and street repairs, without taking on more debt.

This means the city needs at least a $30 million operating surplus, and ideally much more, to avoid dipping into its reserves. Last year’s surplus came in $24 million less than budgeted. This year, the budget started with only a $3 million surplus. And the revenues are already, and predictably, coming in way, way too low.

Advertise with us

In particular, Pittsburgh’s first quarter 2025 revenue report shows significant shortfalls in two taxes that are directly tied to employment in the city: the local services tax (a flat $52 on people who work for employers in the city) and the payroll tax (a 0.55% tax on employers based on their gross payroll expenses).

Both of these are coming in substantially lower than in recent years, and well under budget. This strongly suggests the number of jobs in Pittsburgh proper is dropping — contrary to claims from the mayor’s office, based on trailing data, that the city’s job market is robust.

The stakes

Everyone understands that it’s bad to run out of money, but what does that really mean, in practice?

We can say — as Ms. Heisler has said — that it means even more broken down public safety and public works vehicles, even fewer parks cleanup projects, even less repairing of dilapidated roads and crumbling staircases and rusted bridges. Without a spontaneous economic boom or a significant tax hike (which makes the former even less likely), that’s the reality Pittsburgh is facing. Again.

But even that doesn’t fully capture the stakes. Another fiscal crisis would completely upend the city’s narrative of Rust Belt resurgence and replace it, for decades to come, with a renewed reputation as a post-industrial basket case — and object lesson in how quickly complacency and incompetence can sunder an urban success story.

Advertise with us

It would seem to confirm that Pittsburgh is just not the kind of place you live in if you value economic dynamism and, well, simply having nice things.

Especially if you’re a member of the middle class.

The end

When an urban government fails, the city becomes a place for the rich and the poor. Low-income people are generally unable to decamp to the suburbs, even as they bear the brunt of declines in city services.

Wealthy people, on the other hand, live in neighborhoods that will always be the last to see declines in services. And they can afford private versions of the services they find inadequate: schools, pools, athletics and so on. They can continue to enjoy the benefits of city living while avoiding most or all of the costs.

Members of the middle class, on the other hand, generally have the freedom to leave the city, but not the ability to avoid reliance on public amenities. They live in the city because they like the lifestyle it offers, or they have a connection to a particular neighborhood, or some other personal or ideological reason. But if the costs outweigh the benefits, they will leave.

Advertise with us

And when a city loses its middle class, it loses itself.

Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “Pulling back the curtain on the ugly campaign to re-elect Ed Gainey.”